An African Perspective on the Interplay Between International Solidarity and Vaccine Equity
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25159/2521-2583/16088Keywords:
COVID-19, WTO, WHO, Africa, international solidarity, vaccine equityAbstract
This article explores the relationship between international solidarity and vaccine equity from an African viewpoint. The importance of international solidarity in addressing vaccine inequities has not been properly acknowledged. International bodies such as the United Nations have recognised and articulated both the concept of international solidarity and vaccine equity on a global scale. The patenting of vaccines as regulated by the World Trade Organisation (WTO) often increases vaccine inequities. Compulsory licences are used seldom, leading to calls for a temporary waiver on the WTO’s Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property to enable developing states to manufacture COVID-19 vaccines. To advance vaccine equity during the pandemic, several initiatives such as COVID-19 Vaccines Global Access (COVAX) and the African Union (AU) COVID-19 Vaccine Development and Access Strategy were implemented. While COVAX relied on vaccine donations from developed states, the AU’s approach embraced international solidarity. International solidarity is frequently observed in soft and hard law instruments but not explicitly termed as such. The African approach to international solidarity views it as an obligation of justice; the principle of ubuntu provides useful insights on this concept. Recommendations in this article include forming a collaboration between the World Health Organisation (WHO) and WTO to manage vaccine patents, adopting legal instruments that recognise international solidarity as an obligation and implementing reparative justice. Reparative justice is a comprehensive recommendation since it enables states to manufacture vaccines, maintain their health systems and address patent rights and temporary initiatives simultaneously. As vaccine inequities stem from colonial legacies, it remains to be seen whether a stance will be taken against the powers of affluent states in anticipation of the next pandemic.
References
Africa Centres for Disease Control and Prevention, ‘Adapted African Joint Continental Strategy for COVID-19 Pandemic’ (June 2021).
Africa Centres for Disease Control and Prevention, ‘COVID-19 Vaccine Development and Access Strategy’ (August 2020).
African Union ‘Special Press Briefing to Provide Update on Africa Vaccine Acquisition Task Team (AVATT) Vaccine Deliveries’ (2021) <https://au.int/en/newsevents/20211026/special-press-briefing-provide-update-africa-vaccine-acquisition-task-team-avatt> accessed 27 April 2023.
Ali HA, Hartner A, Echeverria-Londono S, Roth J, Li X, Abbas K, Portnoy A, Vynnycky E, Woodruff K, Ferguson NM, Toor J and Gaythorpe KAM, ‘Vaccine Equity in Low and Middle Income Countries: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis’ [2022] International Journal for Equity in Health.
Archiga A, ‘More Nigerians Take Up COVID Shots After Expired Doses Destroyed’ Reuters (2022) <https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/more-nigerians-take-up-covid-shots-after-expired-doses-destroyed-2022-01-28/> accessed 25 April 2023.
Bélanger M, ‘The Future of International Health Legislation’ [1989] International Digest of Health Legislation.
Bouderhem R, ‘Access to Essential Medicines and International Health Law: Towards a New Paradigm?’ [2022] Asian Journal of WTO and International Health Law and Policy.
Carozza OG and Crema L, ‘On Solidarity in International Law’ (2014) Caritas in Veritate Foundation Report.
ElAteek A, Heikal SA, Rozanova L and Flahault A, ‘Between Ambitious Strategies and Reality: The African Union Strategy on COVID-19 Vaccines’ [2021] Epidemiologia.
Fagbayibo B and Owie UN, ‘Crisis as Opportunity: Exploring the African Union’s Response to COVID-19 and the Implications for Its Aspirational Supranational Powers’ [2021] Journal of African Law.
General Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property 1869 U.N.T.S. 299 33 I.L.M. 1197.
Gostin LO and Taylor O’Neill AL, ‘Global Health Law: A Definition and Grand Challenges’ [2008] Public Health Ethics.
Harman S, Erfani P, Goronga T, Hickel J, Morse M, Richardson ET, ‘Global Vaccine Equity Demands Reparative Justice—Not Charity’ [2021] BMJ Global Health.
Jecker NS and Atuire CA, ‘A Solidarity-Based Approach to Vaccine Allocation’ [2021] Hastings Center Report.
Jecker NS and Atuire CA, ‘What’s Yours is Ours: Waiving Intellectual Property Protections for COVID-19 Vaccines’ [2021] Journal of Medical Ethics.
Jecker NS, ‘Achieving Global Vaccine Equity: The Case for an International Pandemic Treaty’ [2022] Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine.
Jecker NS, Atuire CA and Kenworthy N, ‘Realizing Ubuntu in Global Health: An African Approach to Global Health Justice’ [2022] Public Health Ethics.
Katz IT, Weintraub R, Bekker LG and Brandt Am, ‘From Vaccine Nationalism to Vaccine Equity – Finding A Path Forward’ [2021] The New England Journal of Medicine.
Kovac M and Rakovec L, ‘The COVID-19 Pandemic and Long-Term Incentives for Developing Vaccines: Patent Law Under Stress’ [2021] The Journal of World Intellectual Property.
Kwete X, Tang K, Chen L, Ren R, Chen Q, Wu Z, Cai Y and Li H, ‘Decolonizing Global Health: What Should be the Target of This Movement and Where Does It Lead Us?’ [2020] Global Health Research and Policy.
Lawal L, Bello MA, Murwira T, Avoka C, Ma’aruf SY, Omonhinmin IH, Maluleke P, Tsagkaris C and Onyeaka H, ‘Low Coverage of COVID-19 Vaccines in Africa: Current Evidence and the Way Forward’ [2022] Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics.
Maxim F, ‘Hard Law versus Soft Law in International Law’ [2020] Conferinta Internationala de Drept, Studii Europene si Relatii Internationale.
Mchangama J, ‘Health as a Human Right’ [2009] Center for Politiske Studier.
Medinilla A, Byiers B and Apiko P, ‘African Regional Responses to COVID-19’ (2020) Discussion Paper 272 in European Centre for Development Policy Management.
Merelli A, ‘Europe sent Nigeria up to 1 million near-expired doses of covid-19 vaccine’ (News Article on Quartz 2021) <https://qz.com/africa/2100629/europe-donated-near-expired-doses-of-vaccine-to-african-countries> accessed 24 April 2023.
Mermelstein S and Stevens H, ‘TRIPS to Where? A Narrative Review of the Empirical Literature on Intellectual Property Licensing Models to Promote Global Diffusion of Essential Medicines’ [2022] Pharmaceutics.
Moon S, Bermudes J and Hoen E, ‘Innovation and Access to Medicines for Neglected Populations: Could a Treaty Address a Broken Pharmaceutical R&D System?’ [2012] PLoS Medicine.
New England Board of Higher Education, ‘Reparative Justice’ <https://nebhe.org/reparative-justice/> accessed 8 May 2023.
Note by the Secretary-General, ‘Global Vaccine Solidarity and Human Rights in the Context of the Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) Pandemic’ (2022) UN Doc A/77/173.
Nyabola N, ‘Vaccine Nationalism is Patently Unjust’ The Nation (2021) <https://www.thenation.com/article/world/coronavirus-vaccine-justice/> accessed 28 April 2023.
Okafor OC, ‘International Solidarity’ in De Feyter K, Erdem Türkelli G and De Moerloose S (eds), Encyclopedia of Law and Development (Edward Elgar Publishing Limited 2021).
Okafor OC, ‘International Solidarity, Human Rights and Life on the African Continent “After” the Pandemic’ [2021] Strathmore Law Journal.
Scalzo AA, Alawia N and Rodiqi D, ‘International Solidarity in International Human Rights Law’ [2021] Regional Academy on the United Nations.
Sirleaf M, ‘We Charge Vaccine Apartheid?’ [2022] The Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics.
Skuhravy J, ‘Intellectual Property Rights and Essential Medicines’ [2003] Common Law Review.
Soulé F, ‘Addressing Vaccine Inequity: African Agency and Access to COVID-19 Vaccines’ [2022] China International Strategy Review.
Spade D, ‘Solidarity Not Charity’ [2020] Duke University Press.
Stein F, ‘Risky business: COVAX and the Financialization of Global Vaccine Equity’ [2021] Globalization and Health.
Sykes AO, ‘TRIPs, Pharmaceuticals, Developing Countries, and the Doha “Solution”’ (2002) University of Chicago Law School Working Paper No. 140 <https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.300834> DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.300834
Tatar M, Shoorekchali JM, Faraji MR, Seyyedkolaee MA, Pagán JA and Wilson FA, ‘COVID-19 Vaccine Inequality: A Global Perspective’ [2022] Journal of Global Health.
Taylor AL, ‘Global Health Law: International Law and Public Health Policy’ [2017] Elsevier science.
Van der Graaf R, Browne JL and Baidjoe AY, ‘Vaccine Equity: Past, Present and Future’ [2022] Cell Reports Medicine.
United Nations Economic Commission for Africa, ‘Dealing with Health Pandemics in Africa Through Regional Cooperation: The Case of COVID-19’ (2020) <https://archive.uneca.org/oria/pages/dealing-health-pandemics-africa-through-regional-cooperation-case-covid-19> accessed 28 April 2023.
WHO, ‘COVAX’ (2020) <https://www.who.int/initiatives/act-accelerator/covax> accessed 24 April 2023.
WHO and others, ‘Accelerating COVID-19 Vaccine Deployment’ (G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors Meeting Report 2022).
WTO, ‘Draft Ministerial Decision on the TRIPS Agreement’ (Ministerial Conference, Geneva, 12–15 June 2022).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
