AN EXCLUSIVIST VIEW OF HISTORY WHICH DENIES THE BAPTIST CHURCH CAME OUT OF THE REFORMATION: A LANDMARK RECITAL OF CHURCH HISTORY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25159/2412-4265/456Keywords:
Landmarkism, Landmark, Landmarker, church history, Southern Baptist Convention, Reformation, exclusivist, churchAbstract
The pages of church history reveal that the great variety of Protestant denominations today had their genesis in the Protestant Reformation of the sixteenth century. However, there is a certain strain of Baptist belief, which had its origin in the Southern Baptist Convention in the United States of America in the nineteenth century, which asserts that Baptists did not spring from the Reformation. This view contends that Baptist churches and only Baptist churches have always existed in an unbroken chain of varying names from the first century to the present time. This view is known as Landmarkism. Landmark adherents reject other denominations as true churches, reject the actions of their ministers, and attach to them designations such as societies and organisations rather than churches. Baptist historians today do not espouse such views, however, a surprising number of church members, even among millennials, still hold to such views. This article surveys the origin and spread of such views and provides scholars the means to assess the impact and continuation of Landmark beliefs.Metrics
References
Burnett, J.J. 1991. Sketches of Tennessee’s pioneer Baptist preachers. Nashville, TN: Press of Marshall and Bruce.
Carroll, J.M. 1931. The trail of blood: Following the Christians down through the centuries from the days of Christ to the present time, or, the history of Baptist churches from the time of Christ, their founder, to the present day, 2nd edition. Lexington, KY: Ashland Avenue Baptist Church.
Carver, W.O. 1954. ‘William Heth Whitsitt: The Seminary’s Martyr.’ Review and Expositor 51(4) October 1954: 449-469. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/003463735405100402
Christian, J.T. 1922. A history of the Baptists, together with some account of their principles and practices. Nashville, TN: Sunday School Board of the Southern Baptist Convention.
Graves, J.R. 1860. The tri-lemma, or, death by three horns. Protestants cannot answer this question: ‘Are the baptisms of the Romish Church valid?’ Catholics, Free-will Baptists, Campbellites, and Anti-Missionary Baptists cannot answer this: ‘Are the baptisms of Baptist churches valid?’ Nashville, TN: Southwest Publishing House.
Graves, J.R. 1876. The Graves-Ditzler debate or Great Carrollton debate on the mode of baptism. Memphis, TN: Southern Baptist Publication Society.
Graves, J.R. 1880. Old Landmarkism: What is it? Memphis, TN: Baptist Book House; Graves, Mahaffey & Co.
Johnson’s Universal Cyclopedia: A new edition, prepared by a corps of thirty-six editors, assisted by eminent European and American specialists, under the direction of Charles Kendall Adams, 8 Vols. New York, NY: D. Appleton, A.J. Johnson, 1897.
Mackay, R. LaVerne. 1948. ‘History of the Baptist Church.’ Baptist and Reflector 114(26) 24 June 1948: 7-8.
Orchard, G.H. 1855. A concise history of foreign Baptists: Taken from the New Testament, the first fathers, early writers, and historians of all ages: Chronologically arranged: Exhibiting their distinct communities, with their orders in various kingdoms, under several discriminative appellations from the establishment of Christianity to the present age: With correlative information, supporting the early and only practice of believers’ immersion: Also observations and notes on the abuse of the ordinance, and the rise of minor and infant baptism, with an introductory essay by J. R. Graves. Nashville, TN: Graves, Marks, and Rutland, agents of Tennessee Publication Society; Sheldon Lamport.
Patterson, W.M. 1969. Baptist Successionism: A critical view. Valley Forge, PA: Judson Press.
Sampey, J.R. 1947. Memoirs of John R. Sampey. Nashville, TN: Broadman Press.
Shurden, W.B. 1972. Not a silent people: Controversies that have shaped Southern Baptists. Nashville, TN: Broadman Press.
Tull, J.E. 2000. High-Church Baptists in the South: The origin, nature, and influence of Landmarkism. Edited by Morris Ashcroft. Macon, GA: Mercer University Press.
Tully, H.L. 1938. A Brief history of the Baptists with chapters on baptism, Lord’s Supper, etc. Ensley, AL: Jefferson Printing Co.
Wardin, A.W. Jr. 1999. Tennessee Baptists. Brentwood, TN: Executive Board of the Tennessee Baptist Convention.
Archival material
Baptist and Reflector (Nashville, TN) 23 September 1897 – 1 September 1898.
Dargan, E.C. ‘E.C. Dargan Collection.’ Southern Baptist Historical Library and Archives, Nashville, TN.
Folk, E.E. ‘E.E. Folk Collection.’ Southern Baptist Historical Library and Archives, Nashville, TN.
The Tennessee Baptist (Nashville, TN) 16 November 1848 – 25 February 1854.
Weaver, R.W. ‘Rufus W. Weaver Collection.’ Southern Baptist Historical Library and Archives, Nashville, TN.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Accepted 2016-01-16
Published 2016-05-12
