Transfer Pricing Adjustments: The Different Types, Practical Challenges and Recommended Approaches—A South African Perspective

Annet Oguttu

doi:10.25159/2522-3062/10017

Authors

Annet Oguttu University of Pretoria https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1795-6669

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25159/2522-3062/10017

Keywords:

transfer pricing, primary adjustments, secondary adjustments, corresponding adjustments, economic double taxation, mutual agreement procedure

Abstract

This article concerns the tax policy and practical challenges that arise from applying the various transfer pricing adjustments. The lack of clear international guidelines on how to address some issues regarding transfer pricing adjustments and the diverging policy positions that some countries have taken, pose uncertainties for taxpayers and tax disputes which can impede international trade. These challenges are addressed in the article by focusing on the South African position and providing recommendations on how to resolve some of them. The explanation of the murky issues regarding transfer pricing adjustments will be found instrumental for developing countries where the legislation, administration and practice of transfer pricing are not yet well developed. The article’s focus is on South Africa, an emerging economy on the African continent, which is used as a base for many MNEs that invest in the rest of Africa. It will be useful for foreign investors to gain an understanding of South Africa’s position on transfer pricing adjustments.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Ajam T and Davis D, ‘The Consequence of Near-Total Cessation of Economic Activity and then a Somewhat Haphazard Partial Opening up of the Economy is Wreaking Havoc with South Africa’s Tax Base’ Daily Maverick (14 May 2020).

Andersen Tax, ‘Review of Transfer Pricing Development in Africa: A Study of Key Sub-Saharan African Countries’ <https://andersentax.ng/docs/review_of_transfer_pricing_development_in_africa_10042019.pdf> accessed 25 September 2020.

Arnold B and Mclyntyre JM, International Tax Primer (The Hague, Kluwer Law International 2002).

Arnold BJ, International Tax Primer (3rd edn, Wolters Kluwer 2016).

ATAF, ‘Tax Administration and Policy Developments in Response to the Coronavirus (COVID-19) Pandemic in Africa’ (July 2020).

BDO, Global Customs and Transfer Pricing: Year-end Adjustments (7 December 2020) <https://www.bdo.global/en-gb/insights/tax/transfer-pricing/realise-customs-and-transfer-pricing-year-end-adjustments> accessed 12 April 2021.

Barsalou Lawson Advocates – Canada, ‘Reply to the Invitation to Comment on the OECD’s New Project on Administrative Aspects of Transfer Pricing’ (30 June 2011) <https://www.oecd.org/ctp/transfer-pricing/48323702.pdf> accessed 23 October 2020.

Brodbeck J and Gers C, ‘South Africa: The New South African Transfer Pricing Rules may be Risky’ International Tax Review (2012).

Cottani G, ‘Transfer Pricing, Topical Analyses’ (2016, IBFD).

DTC, ‘BEPS Interim Report on Action Plan 13: Transfer Pricing Documentation’ (2014).

Dirk VS and Lim K, ‘Year-end Adjustments: What Tune is the EU Singing?’ (2012) Tax Management Transfer Pricing Report 20, 1014.

Dosal J and Kratz M, COVID-19 and Transfer Pricing: Year-end Adjustments (27 January 2021) <https://www.rsm.global/insights/tax-news/covid-19-and-transfer-pricing-year-end-adjustments> accessed 12 April 2021.

Dwarkasing RSJ, ‘Associated Enterprises: A Concept Essential for the Application of the Arm’s Length Principle and Transfer Pricing’ (LLD dissertation, Tilburg University 2011).

EC Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base Working Group (2007) <https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/taxation/files/docs/body/ccctbwp057_en.pdf> accessed 5 August 2022.

European Commission, ‘EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum Final Report on Secondary Adjustments’ (2013).

European Commission, ‘EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum, Member States’ Responses to Questionnaire on compensating adjustments/Year-end adjustments, JTPF/019/REV1/2011/EN (2011).

EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum, ‘Report on Compensating Adjustments’ (2014) DOC: JTPF/009/FINAL/2013/EN <https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/taxation/files/resources/documents/taxation/company_tax/transfer_pricing/forum/jtpf/2013/jtpf_009_final_2013_en.pdf> accessed 22 October 2020.

HMR&C Consultation Document, ‘Introduction of secondary adjustments into the UK’s domestic transfer pricing legislation’ (26 May 2016).

Hanken J and Doward R, ‘A Fresh View on the Out-come Testing Approach Versus Price Setting Approach Discussion and Recommendations Regarding the Benchmarking Studies’ (2014) International Transfer Pricing Journal 21(6).

Harmse L and Van der Zwan P, ‘Alternatives for the Treatment of Transfer Pricing Adjustments in South Africa’ De Jure 49(2) (2016) <https://doi.org/10.17159/2225-7160/2016/v49n2a6> DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/2225-7160/2016/v49n2a6

Hay D, Horner F and Owens J, ‘Past and Present Work in the OECD on Transfer Pricing and Selected Issues’ (1994) Intertax <https://doi.org/10.54648/TAXI1994058> DOI: https://doi.org/10.54648/TAXI1994058

Jenks TE, ‘Constructive Dividends Resulting from Section 482 Adjustments’ (1970) Tax Lawyer.

Jones A Bulletin – Tax Treaty Monitor, International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation (2001).

Joubert B and Isaac N, ‘Transfer Pricing: Arm’s Length Standard – Secondary Transfer Pricing Adjustments’ <https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/za/Documents/tax/ZA_Secondaryadjustment_090615.pdf> accessed 20 October 2020.

KPMG, ‘Tax and Legal News Letter’ <https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/pdf/2016/05/LV-Tax-Legal-ENG-May-2016.pdf> accessed 22 October 2020.

Khan K, ‘The Relationship Between Transfer Pricing Adjustments and Withholding Tax on Interest in South Africa’ Potchefstroom: North-West University (Mini-dissertation) (2020).

Kofler G, ‘Article 9: Associated Enterprises’ in Ekkehart Reimer and Alexander Rust (eds), Klaus Vogel on Double Taxation Conventions (Kluwer Law International 2015).

Kruger J, ‘South African Transfer Pricing - a Paradigm Shift in the Dark’ (2012) TaxFind.

Lang M, ‘Qualification Conflicts’ in R Van (ed) Global Tax Treaty Commentaries (2008).

League of Nations, ‘Taxation of Foreign and National Enterprises: Vol IV, Methods of Allocating Taxable Income’ Document No C425(b) M 217(b)1933.II.A (1933).

Mckinley J and Owsley J, ‘Transfer Pricing and its Effect on Financial Reporting’ (1 October 2013) Journal of Accountancy.

Miesel HV, Higinbotham HH and Yi WC, ‘International Transfer Pricing: Practical Solutions for Inter-Company Pricing – Part II’ (2003) 29 International Tax Journal.

National Treasury, ‘Explanatory Memorandum to the Taxation Laws Amendment Bill’ (2011).

OECD, ‘BEPS Action 5 on Harmful Tax Practices: Transparency Framework: Peer Review Documents (February 2021).

OECD, ‘Guidance on Transfer Pricing Implications of the Covid-19 Pandemic’ (2020).

OECD, ‘Implementing the BEPS Packaged: Building an Inclusive Framework’ (February 2016) https://www.oecd.org/.../flyer-implementing-the-beps-package-building-an-inclusive-> accessed 10 October 2019.

OECD, ‘Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital’ (Commentary on Article 9) (2017).

OECD, Issues in International Taxation No 2 Thin Capitalisation: Taxation of Entertainers, Artists and Sportsmen (OECD Publishing 1987).

OECD, Review of Comparability and of Profit Methods: Revision of Chapters I-III of The Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2010) para 1.13 <http://www.oecd.org/tax/transfer-pricing/45763692.pdf> accessed 5 November 2018.

OECD, Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations Paris, (2022, OECD Publishing).

OECD/G20 BEPS Project, ‘Countering Harmful Tax Practices More Effectively, Taking into Account Transparency and Substance: Action 5’ (OECD Publishing 2015).

OECD/G20 BEPS Project, ‘Harmful Tax Practices – 2019 Peer Review Reports on the Exchange of Information on Tax Rulings: Inclusive Framework on BEPS: Action 5 (OECD Publishing 2020).

OECD/G20 BEPS Project, ‘Making Dispute Resolution More Effective – MAP Peer Review Report, South Africa (Stage 1): Inclusive Framework on BEPS: Action 14 (OECD Publishing 2019).

OECD/G20 BEPS Project, Aligning Transfer Pricing Outcomes with Value Creation: Actions 8-10 (OECD Publishing 2015).

OECD/G20, ‘Public Consultation Document – Global Anti-Base Erosion Proposal (‘GloBE’): Pillar Two (8 November 2019 – 2 December 2019)’ <https://www.oecd.org/tax/beps/public-consultation-document-global-anti-base-erosion-proposal-pillar-two.pdf.pdf> accessed 23 August 2020.

O’Brien JM and Oates MA, ‘Why Triangular Constructive Dividends/Capital Contributions have no place in code Sec. 482 cases’ International Tax Journal 35(6) (2009).

Obitax ‘Malawi Publishes Transfer Pricing Regulations 2017’ <https://www.orbitax.com/news/archive.php/Malawi-Publishes-Transfer-Pric-26259> accessed 26 September 2020.

Oguttu A, ‘Base Erosion and Profit Shifting: A Blue Print for Africa’s Response’ (IBFD 2021).

Oguttu A, ‘Challenges of Applying the Comparability Analysis in Curtailing Transfer Pricing: Evaluating the Suitability of Some Alternative Approaches in Africa’ (2020) Intertax 48(1) <https://doi.org/10.54648/TAXI2020006> DOI: https://doi.org/10.54648/TAXI2020006

Oguttu A, ‘Developing South Africa as a Gateway for Foreign Investment in Africa: A Critique of South Africa’s Headquarter Company Regime’ (2011) 36 South African Yearbook of International Law.

Oguttu A, ‘Resolving Double Tax Treaty Disputes: The Challenges of Mutual Agreement Procedure with a Special Focus on Addressing the Concerns of Developing Countries in Africa — The South African and Ugandan Experience’ (2015) South African Yearbook of International Law..

PWC, ‘Comment Letter in Response to OECD Consultation Paper on the Unified Approach under Pillar 1 (12 November 2019) 11e’ <https://www.pwc.com/us/en/tax-services/publications/insights/assets/OECD-Pillar-1-Paper-PwC-Response-Final.pdf> accessed 27 April 2020.

Plasschaert SRF, Transfer Pricing and Multinational Cooperation: An Overview of Concepts, Mechanisms and Regulations (Farnborough, Saxon House 1979).

Preiss M and Szymańska K, ‘Transfer Pricing Adjustments in Multinational Enterprises: Yet Another Challenge for Taxpayers’ (16 September 2019) <https://home.kpmg/pl/en/home/insights/2019/09/transfer-pricing-adjustments-in-multinational-enterprises-yet-another-challenge-for-taxpayers.htm> accessed 22 October 2020.

Rawal R, Radhakishan Rawal’s Analysis of the Finance Acts of 2019 and More (Bloomberg Publishing 2019).

‘Return to be Submitted by Persons in Terms of Section 25 of The Tax Administration Act, 2011 (Act No. 28 of 2011)’ (20 October 2017) GG 41186.

SAICA, ‘International Tax: Transfer Pricing’ <https://www.saica.co.za/integritax/2000/763_Transfer_pricing.htm> accessed 22 October 2020.

SARS, ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution: What to do if you Dispute your Tax Assessment and the Dispute Resolution Guide: Guide on the Rules Promulgated in terms of Section 103 of the Tax Administration Act, 2011’ (2014).

SARS, ‘Guide on Mutual Agreement Procedures – Issue 3’ (SARS 20 March 2020).

SARS, ‘Practice Note: No 7 Section 31 of the Income Tax Act 1962: Determination of Taxable Income of Certain Persons from International Taxation: Transfer Pricing’ (6 August 1999).

Schoeneborn F, ‘Outcome Testing: Why Year-end Adjustments Cannot be the First Choice to Bring Intercompany Margins to an Arm’s Length Level’ (2015) 22(3) International Transfer Pricing Journal.

Söderberg Oskar Paladini, ‘Compensating Adjustments - An international Perspective’ (Master of Laws, Lund University 2018).

The BEPS Monitoring Group, ‘Explanation and Analysis of the MLI’ (2016).

UN, Handbook on Selected Issues in Administration of Double Tax Treaties for Developing Countries (UN New York, UN 2013).

UN, Practical Manual on Transfer Pricing for Developing Countries (New York, UN 2017).

WHO, ‘Virtual Press Conference on COVID-19’ (11 March 2020) <https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/transcripts/who-audio-emergencies-coronavirus-press-conference-full-and-final-11mar2020.pdf?sfvrsn=cb432bb3_2> accessed 3 September 2020.

Webber Wentzel, Chambers Global Practical Guide ‘Corporate Tax: South Africa’ (2020).

Wilkie JS, ‘Canada – Downward Transfer Pricing Adjustments: Dow Chemical Canada ULC v The Queen’ (2021) 28(3) International Transfer Pricing Journal.

Wittendorf J, Transfer Pricing and the Arm's Length Principle in International Tax Law (Kluwer Law International 2010).

Wittendorf J, ‘Transfer Pricing Timing Issues Revisited’ Tax Notes International (2012) 68(1).

Cases

ABC (Pty) Ltd v Commissioner: SARS (IT 14305) [2021] ZATC 1.

Crookes Brothers Ltd v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service [2018] ZAGPHC 311.

Dow Chemical Canada ULC v The Queen, 2020 TCC 139.

ITC 167, 62 SATC 219.

Statutes

Income Tax Act 58 of 1968.

Malawi Government Notice 36 of 2017.

Taxation Laws Amendment Act 34 of 2019.

Treaties, Conventions

Convention Between the Republic of South Africa and Canada For the Avoidance of Double Taxation and The Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to Taxes on Income (30 April 1997) (Treaties & Models IBFD, SA GG) 17985) (entered into force 07 May 1997.

Convention Between the Republic of South Africa and The Kingdom of The Netherlands for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital Government (10 October 2005) (Treaties & Models IBFD SA GG 31797) (entered into force 28 December 2008.

Convention Between the Republic of South Africa and the Swiss Confederation for the Avoidance of Double Taxation with Respect to Taxes on Income (8 May 2007) (Treaties & Models IBFD, SAGG 31967) entered into force 27 January 2009.

OECD ‘Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent Base Erosion and Profit Shifting’ (2016).

EU ‘Convention on the Elimination of Double Taxation in Connection with the Adjustment of Profits of Associated Enterprises’ 90/436/EEC.