The African Court’s Jurisdiction over the Crime of Unconstitutional Change of Government and the African Union’s Sanctions Regime: A Comparative Analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25159/2522-3062/11635Keywords:
Unconstitutional change of government, African Court, African Union, Malabo Protocol, sanctions regime, military coups, Article 28EAbstract
This paper provides a comparative assessment of the criminalisation of unconstitutional change of government before the proposed African Court of Justice and Human Rights (African Court), and the African Union’s sanctions regime, which is part of its legal and policy framework to respond to unconstitutional change of government. Using Niger and Gabon as case studies, the paper examines the efficacy of the African Union (and the Economic Community of West African States, in the case of Niger) sanctions regime in response to the recent military coups in these selected countries. It is argued that the African Union’s policy and legal framework in response to unconstitutional change of government and the sanctions regime have not been effective in countering the scourge of unconstitutional change of government on the African continent. The paper then examines the potential of Article 28E of the Malabo Protocol, which criminalises unconstitutional change of government, to effectively address the problem of recurring unconstitutional change of government in Africa. It concludes that this Article has the potential to effectively address the problem of unconstitutional change of government when the African Court becomes operational.
Metrics
References
Abass A, ‘Historical and Political Background to the Malabo Protocol’ in Werle G and Vormbaum M (eds), The African Criminal Court: A Commentary on the Malabo Protocol (Springer 2017) <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-150-0_2> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-150-0_2
Abebe A, ‘Denounce Guinea’s Coup—and Incumbent Leaders’ Abuses of Power’ (Foreign Policy, 20 September 2021) <https://www.foreignpolicy.com/2021/09/20/guinea-coup-au-ecowas-incumbents-constitutional/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Africa Centre for Strategic Studies, ‘Understanding Burkina Faso’s Latest Coup’ (28 October 2022) <https://africacenter.org/spotlight/understanding-burkina-faso-latest-coup/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Ajala A, ‘Botched Coup in Niger Points to Deep Fissures in the Country’ (The Conversation, 2 April 2021) <https://theconversation.com/botched-coup-in-niger-points-to-deep-fissures-in-the-country-158330> accessed 11 November 2023.
Al Jazeera, ‘Timeline: What Has Happened in Niger Since the Coup?’ (Al Jazeera, 20 August 2023) <https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2023/8/20/timeline-what-has-happened-in-niger-since-the-coup> accessed 11 November 2023.
Aubut J, ‘The Good Governance Agenda: Who Wins and Who Loses. Some Empirical Evidence for 2001’ (2004) London School of Economics Working Paper Series 11.
AU, ‘Communiqué of the 996th meeting of the Peace and Security Council of the African Union on the Consideration of the Report of the Fact-Finding Mission to the Republic of Chad, 14 May 2021’ <https://www.peaceau.org/en/article/communique-of-the-996th-meeting-of-the-peace-and-security-council-of-the-african-union-on-the-consideration-of-the-report-of-the-fact-finding-mission-to-the-republic-of-chad-14-may-2021> last updated 16 June 2021.
AU Declaration on Terrorism and Unconstitutional Changes of Government in Africa (28 May 2022) Ext/Assembly/AU/Decl. (XVI) <https://au.int/en/pressreleases/20220528/declaration-terrorism-and-unconstitutional-changes-government-africa> accessed 11 November 2023.
AU–EU Expert Report on the Principle of Universal Jurisdiction (Brussels, 16 July 2009) <https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/ST%208672%202009%20REV%201/EN/pdf> accessed 11 November 2023.
AU Panel of the Wise, ‘Peace, Justice and Reconciliation in Africa: Opportunities and Challenges in the Fight against Impunity’ (The African Union Series, New York: International Peace Institute, 2013).
AU PSC, ‘Communique of the 1168th Meeting of the PSC Held on 14 August 2023, on Updated Briefing on the Situation in Niger’ (14 August 2023) <https://www.peaceau.org/uploads/1168.comm-en.pdf> accessed 11 November 2023.
AU PSC, ‘Accra Declaration on Unconstitutional Changes of Government in Africa, 15–17 March 2022, Accra, Ghana’ <https://papsrepository.africa-union.org/handle/123456789/1572> accessed 11 November 2023.
AU PSC, ‘Communique of the 1172nd of the PSC Held on 31 August 2023, on the Situation in the Republic of Gabon’ (31 August 2023) <https://www.peaceau.org/en/article/communique-of-the-1172nd-of-the-psc-held-on-31-august-2023-on-the-situation-in-the-republic-of-gabon> last updated 1 September 2023.
AU PSC, ‘Communiqué of the Chairperson of the AU Commission in Support of the 10 August 2023 ECOWAS Decisions regarding Niger’ (11 August 2023) <https://au.int/en/pressreleases/20230811/communique-support-10-august-2023-ecowas-decisions-regarding-niger> accessed 11 November 2023.
AU PSC, ‘Communiqué of the 1180th meeting of the PSC, Held on 23 October 2023, Dedicated to the Situation in the Republic of Gabon’ (23 October 2023) <https://www.peaceau.org/en/article/communique-of-the-1180th-meeting-of-the-psc-held-on-23-october-2023-dedicated-to-the-situation-in-the-republic-of-gabon> accessed 11 November 2023.
AU, ‘Protocol on Amendments to the Constitutive Act of the African Union, Status List’ <https://www.au.int/en/treaties/protocol-amendments-constitutive-act-african-union> accessed 13 April 2022.
AU, Protocol Relating to the Establishment of the Peace and Security Council of the African Union, Status List <https://www.au.int/en/treaties/protocol-relating-establishment-peace-and-security-council-african-union> accessed 13 April 2022.
AU, ‘African Charter for Democracy, Elections and Governance, Status List’ <https://www.au.int/en/treaties/african-charter-democracy-elections-and-governance> accessed 13 April 2022.
AU, ‘Protocol on Amendments to the Protocol on the Statute of the African Court of Justice and Human Rights: Status List’ <https://au.int/sites/default/files/treaties/36398-sl-PROTOCOL%20ON%20AMENDMENTS%20TO%20THE%20PROTOCOL%20ON%20THE%20STATUTE%20OF%20THE%20AFRICAN%20COURT%20OF%20JUSTICE%20AND%> accessed 11 November 2023.
AU, ‘Press Release from the Chairperson of the African Union Commission on the Situation in Gabon’ (30 August 2023) <https://au.int/en/pressreleases/20230830/press-release-situation-gabon> accessed 11 November 2023.
Barka HB, and Ncube M, ‘Political Fragility in Africa: Are Military Coups d’état a Never-Ending Phenomenon?’ (AfDB Chief Economist Complex, September 2012) <https://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Publications/Economic%20Brief%20%20Political%20Fragility%20in%20Africa%20Are%20Military%20Coups%20d%E2%80%99Etat%20a%20Never%20Ending%20Phenomenon.pdf> accessed 13 April 2022.
BBC News, ‘Chad President’s Death: Rivals Condemn “Dynastic Coup”’ (BBC News, 21 April 2021) <https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-56830510> accessed 13 April 2022.
Buchan R and Tsagourias N, ‘The Niger Coup and the Prospect of ECOWAS Military Intervention: An International Law Appraisal’ (Lieber Institute West Point, 21 August 2023) <https://lieber.westpoint.edu/niger-coup-ecowas-military-intervention-international-law-appraisal/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Clarke K, Jalloh C and Nmehielle V, ‘Introduction: Origins and Issues of the African Court of Justice and Human and Peoples’ Rights’ in Jalloh C, Clarke K and Nmehielle V (eds), The African Court of Justice and Human Rights in Context: Development and Challenges (CUP 2019) <https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108525343>
Decision on Africa’s Relationship with the International Criminal Court (ICC) Ext/Assembly/AU/Dec (October 2013).
Derso S, ‘Unconstitutional Changes of Government and Unconstitutional Practices in Africa’ (African Politics, African Peace, Paper No. 2, June 2016)
De Wet E, ‘The African Union’s Struggle against “Unconstitutional Change of Government”: From a Moral Prescription to a Requirement under International Law?’ (2021) 32 (1) European Journal of International Law <https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chab015> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chab015
Dube A, ‘The AU Model Law on Universal Jurisdiction: An African Response to Western Prosecutions Based on the Universality Principle’ (2015) 18 (3) PELJ <https://doi.org/10.4314/pelj.v18i3.01> DOI: https://doi.org/10.4314/pelj.v18i3.01
Dube R, ‘Fighting Unconstitutional Changes in Government or Merely Politicking? A Critical Analysis of the African Union Response’ (MA dissertation University of Pretoria 2010) <http://hdl.handle.net/2263/16775>
Du Plessis M, ‘Implications of the AU Decision to Give the African Court Jurisdiction over International Crimes’ (Institute for Security Studies Paper 235, June 2012) <https://issafrica.org/research/papers/implications-of-the-au-decision-to-give-the-african-court-jurisdiction-over-international-crimes> accessed 11 November 2023.
ECOWAS Commission, ‘Final Communiqué—Extraordinary Summit of the ECOWAS Authority of Heads of State and Government on the Political Situation in Niger’ (30 July 2023) <https://ecowas.int/final-communique-fifty-first-extraordinary-summit-of-the-ecowas-authority-of-heads-of-state-and-government-on-the-political-situation-in-niger/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Elvy S, ‘Towards a New Democratic Africa: The African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance’ (2013) 27 Emory International Law Review <https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2292733> DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2292733
Enonchong L, ‘Chad’s “Covert Coup” and the Implications for Democratic Governance in Africa’ (The Conversation, 24 May 2021) <https://www.theconversation.com/chads-covert-coup-and-the-implications-for-democratic-governance-in-africa-159725> accessed 13 April 2022.
Fisayo-Bambi J, ‘Niger: Black Outs from One of ECOWAS Sanctions Hurting Business’ (Africa News, 13 August 2023) <https://www.africanews.com/2023/08/13/niger-black-outs-from-one-of-ecowas-sanctions-that-cut-off-electricity-hurting-business//> accessed 21 February 2024.
Fombad C, ‘Countering the Scourge of Unconstitutional Changes of Government in Africa’ (IACL-AIDC Blog, 16 June 2022) <https://blog-iacl-aidc.org/new-blog-3/2022/6/16/countering-the-scourge-of-unconstitutional-changes-of-government-in-africa-m24ny> accessed 11 November 2023.
Hamady O, ‘Assessing the Legality of ECOWAS Planned Military Intervention in Niger’ (EJIL Talk, 6 September 2023) <https://www.ejiltalk.org/assessing-the-legality-of-ecowas-planned-military-intervention-in-niger/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Handy P-S and Djilo F, ‘AU Balancing Act on Chad’s Coup Sets a Disturbing Precedent’ (Institute for Security Studies, 2 June 2021) <https://issafrica.org/iss-today/au-balancing-act-on-chads-coup-sets-a-disturbing-precedent> accessed 13 April 2022.
Harshe R, ‘Untangling Niger’s Military Coup’ (Observer Research Foundation, 26 August 2023) <https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/untangling-nigers-military-coup/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Institute for Security Studies, ‘The AU Reneges on Its Stance against Coups d’états’ (PSC Report, 27 May 2021) <https://issafrica.org/pscreport/psc-insights/the-au-reneges-on-its-stance-against-coups-detat> accessed 13 April 2022.
Jalloh C, Clarke K and Nmehielle V (eds), The African Court of Justice and Human Rights in Context: Development and Challenges (CUP 2019) <https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108525343> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108525343
Jezequel J-H, ‘Mali, a Coup within a Coup’ (International Crisis Group, 27 May 2021) <https://www.crisisgroup.org/africa/sahel/mali/mali-un-coup-dans-le-coup > accessed 11 November 2023.
Kemp G and Kinyunyu S, ‘The Crime of Unconstitutional Change of Government’ in Werle G and Vormbaum M (eds), The African Criminal Court—A Commentary on the Malabo Protocol (Springer 2017) <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-150-0_4> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-150-0_4
Kottasova I and Mackintosh E, ‘The Military Has Taken Over in Sudan. Here’s What Happened’ (CNN News, 25 October 2021) <https://www.edition.cnn.com/2021/10/25/africa/sudan-coup-explained-intl-cmd/index.html> accessed 11 November 2023.
Krasteva G, ‘Sanctions Have “No Impact” on Putin but Could Cause Famine in Russia, Expert Warns’ (Metro News, 5 March 2022) <https://metro.co.uk/2022/03/05/sanctions-have-no-impact-on-putin-but-could-cause-famine-in-russia-16217950/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Leininger J, ‘A Strong Norm for Democratic Governance in Africa’ (International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, 2014) <https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2544090> DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2544090
Los Angeles Times, ‘Mercenary Leads Coup in Comoros off African Coast’ (29 September 1995) <https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1995-09-29-mn-51357-story.html> accessed 13 April 2022.
Mahdi M, ‘Africa’s International Crimes Court Is Still a Pipe Dream’ (ISS Today, 15 October 2019) <https://issafrica.org/iss-today/africas-international-crimes-court-is-still-a-pipe-dream> accessed 11 November 2023.
Mamane D and Asadu C, ‘Many in Niger Are Suffering under Coup-Related Sanctions. Junta Backers Call It a Worthy Sacrifice’ (AP News, 26 October 2023) <https://apnews.com/article/niger-bazoum-coup-sanctions-ecowas-c7bdfd06559f1cfbfb856bea5b11a55f> accessed 11 November 2023.
Mangu A, ‘The Role of the African Union and Regional Economic Communities in the Implementation of the African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance’ (2018) 5 (3) African Journal of Democracy and Governance.
Manirakiza P, ‘Insecurity Implications of Unconstitutional Changes of Government in Africa: From Military to Constitutional Coups’ (2016) 17 (2) Journal of Military and Strategic Studies.
Matlosa K, Shale V, and Motsamai D, ‘Preventing and Managing Violent Electoral Related Conflict: Exploring Good Practices’ (Electoral Institute of Southern Africa, 2009).
Mbara G and Graham S, ‘Dissecting the Impact of Recent Coups in Africa on Democracy and Good Governance’ (2023) 20 (2) African Renaissance.
Mednick S, ‘Leader of Niger’s Junta Says It Will Restore Civilian Rule within 3 Years, but Gives No Details’ (AP News, 20 August 2023) <https://apnews.com/article/niger-coup-jihadis-ecowas-d704ef6c5add00a37c6ee931d2f7561d> accessed 11 November 2023.
Murungu C, ‘Towards a Criminal Chamber in the African Court of Justice and Human Rights’ (2011) 9 Journal of International Criminal Justice <https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqr053> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqr053
Mushoriwa L, ‘The Relationship between State Sovereignty and International Criminal Law in Africa as Seen through the Lens of the Application of the Principles of Immunity and Universal Jurisdiction’ (PhD thesis University of KwaZulu-Natal 2018) <https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/304374709.pdf>
Mushoriwa L, ‘The African Union’s Role in Addressing the Scourge of Conflict in Africa’ (ISPI Online, 27 May 2022) <https://www.ispionline.it/en/publication/african-unions-role-addressing-scourge-conflict-africa-35200> accessed 11 November 2022.
Mushoriwa L, ‘The African Union’s Quest for a “Peaceful and Secure Africa”: An Assessment of Aspiration Four of Agenda 2063’ (2023) 27 Law, Democracy and Development <https://doi.org/10.17159/2077-4907/2023/ldd.v27.3> DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/2077-4907/2023/ldd.v27.3
Mushoriwa L, ‘Another Military Coup in Niger: What Next for the AU and ECOWAS?’ (African Law Matters Blog, 14 August 2023) <https://www.africanlawmatters.com/blog/another-military-coup-in-niger> accessed 11 November 2023.
Mwangi D, ‘Deferral and Enforcement Powers of the United Nations Security Council under the Rome Statute: A Case Study of Kenya’ (2016) 4 (7) International Journal of Education and Research.
Nathan L, ‘African Solutions to African Problems? South Africa’s Foreign Policy’ (September/October 2013) 92 WeltTrends.
Ncube S, ‘At Issue—Reframing the African Peace and Security Architecture: An Argument for a Unitary AU Post-conflict Reconstruction and Development Organ’ (2020) 19 (1) African Studies Quarterly.
Ndulo M, ‘The Prohibition of Unconstitutional Change of Government’ in Yusuf A A and Ouguergouz F (eds), The African Union: Legal and Institutional Framework: A Manual on the Pan-African Organization (Martinus Nijhoff 2012) <https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004227729_014> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004227729_014
Nyinevi C and Fosu R, ‘The African Union’s Prohibition of Unconstitutional Changes of Government: An Uneasy Choice between Fidelity to Principle and Pragmatism’ (2023) 16 (1) African Security <https://doi.org/10.1080/19392206.2023.2195748> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19392206.2023.2195748
Obangome G, ‘Gabon Officers Declare Military Coup, President Ali Bongo Detained’ (Reuters, 31 August 2023) <https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/gabonese-military-officers-announce-they-have-seized-power-2023-08-30/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Okechukwu N, ‘The Fragility of the African Governance Agenda: A Crisis of Legitimacy’ (ecdpm Briefing Note No. 171, 30 October 2023) <https://ecdpm.org/work/fragility-african-governance-agenda-crisis-legitimacy> accessed 11 November 2023.
Omorogbe E, ‘A Club of Incumbents? The African Union and Coups d’etat’ (2011) 44 Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law.
Onuah F, ‘Niger Coup: West African Bloc Activates Standby Force for Possible Intervention’ (Reuters, 11 August 2023) <https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/west-african-leaders-aim-agree-next-steps-defiant-niger-junta-2023-08-10/> accessed 11 November 2023.
Protocol on Amendments to the Protocol on the African Court of Justice and Human Rights (Malabo Protocol) adopted 27 June 2014 <https://au.int/en/treaties/protocol-amendments-protocol-statute-african-court-justice-and-human-rights> accessed 21 February 2024.
Protocol A/SP1/12/01 on Democracy and Good Governance Supplementary to the Protocol Relating to the Mechanism for Conflict Prevention, Management, Resolution, Peacekeeping and Security <https://www.eisa.org/pdf/ecowas2001protocol.pdf> accessed 11 November 2023.
Ssenyonjo M, ‘The Crime of Unconstitutional Change of Government and Popular Uprisings in Africa: Issues and Challenges’ 28 (3) African Journal of International and Comparative Law <https://doi.org/10.3366/ajicl.2020.0322> DOI: https://doi.org/10.3366/ajicl.2020.0322
Sirleaf M, ‘Prosecuting Dirty Dumping in Africa’ in Jalloh C, Clarke K and Nmehielle V (eds), The African Court of Justice and Human and Peoples’ Rights in Context: Opportunity and Challenges (CUP 2019) <https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108525343.021> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108525343.021
Sithole T, ‘A Review of the African Union Framework and Mechanism on Peace and Security’ (2018) 7 (1) Journal of African Union Studies <https://doi.org/10.31920/2050-4306/2018/v7n1a4> DOI: https://doi.org/10.31920/2050-4306/2018/v7n1a4
Souaré I, ‘The AU and the Challenge of Unconstitutional Changes of Government in Africa’ (Paper 197 Institute for Security Studies, 2009).
Souaré I, ‘The African Union as a Norm Entrepreneur on Military Coups d’état in Africa (1952–2012): An Empirical Assessment’ (2014) 52 (1) Journal of Modern African Studies <https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022278X13000785> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022278X13000785
Suleiman M, ‘Towards a Better Understanding of the Underlying Conditions of Coups in Africa’ (E-International Relations 24 September 2021) <https://www.e-ir.info/2021/09/24/towards-a-better-understanding-of-the-underlying-conditions-of-coups-in-africa/> accessed 13 April 2022.
Tladi D, ‘Immunities (Article 46 A bis)’ in Werle G and Vormbaum M (eds), The African Criminal Court: A Commentary on the Malabo Protocol (Springer 2017) <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-150-0_12> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-150-0_12
Tiba F, ‘Regional International Criminal Courts: An Idea Whose Time Has Come?’ (2016) 17 Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution.
Van der Wilt H, ‘Unconstitutional Change of Government: A New Crime within the Jurisdiction of the African Criminal Court’ in Jalloh C, Clarke K and Nmehielle V (eds), The African Court of Justice and Human and Peoples’ Rights in Context: Development and Challenges (CUP 2019) <https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108525343.023> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108525343.023
Yeboua K, ‘Africa Can End Its Rash of Military Coups: But Sanctions Aren’t Enough—The AU and States Must Tackle Root Causes, Including Electoral Fraud and Service Delivery Failure’ (Institute for Security Studies, 5 October 2023) <https://issafrica.org/iss-today/africa-can-end-its-rash-of-military-coups> accessed 11 November 2023.
Yeung J, ‘Gabon’s Military Coup Has Overthrown a Powerful Political Dynasty. Here’s What to Know’ (CNN, 31 August 2023) <https://edition.cnn.com/2023/08/31/africa/gabon-military-coup-explainer-intl-hnk/index.html> accessed 11 November 2023.
International Legal Instruments and Conventions
African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance (adopted 30 July 2007).
Constitutive Act of the African Union (adopted 9 July 2000).
ECOWAS Supplementary Protocol on Democracy and Good Governance A/SP1/12/01) (December 2001).
Ezulwini Framework for the Enhancement of the Implementation of Measures of the African Union in Situations of Unconstitutional Changes of Government in Africa (Ezulwini, Kingdom of Swaziland, 17–19 December 2009) <https://www.peaceau.org/uploads/ezulwini-framework-english.pdf > accessed 13 April 2022.
Lome Declaration of July 2000 on the Framework for an OAU Response to Unconstitutional Changes of Government (AHG/Decl. 5) (XXXVI).
Protocol Relating to the Establishment of the Peace and Security Council of the African Union (adopted 9 July 2002).
Protocol on Amendments to the Protocol on the Statute for the African Court of Justice and Human Rights (27/7/2014) 70th Ordinary Session of the OAU Council of Ministers, Algiers 8–10 July 1999, CM /Dec. 483 (LXX).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
© Published by the Department of Public, Constitutional and International Law, University of South Africa and Unisa Press.
Accepted 2024-02-02
Published 2024-04-16
