Confronting the Shortcomings of Land Restitution in South Africa—Arguments for a Positively Framed Property Clause: The German Example
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25159/2522-3062/15800Keywords:
land restitution, property clause, restitution of the Land Rights Act, South Africa, GermanyAbstract
Section 28 of the Interim Constitution of the Republic of South Africa paved the way for the inclusion of a property clause in South Africa’s final Constitution by providing for the constitutional protection of property. It was worded positively in so far as it explicitly guaranteed the right to acquire and hold rights in property. This positive formulation of South Africa’s draft property clause resembled the German property clause. Several problems were identified that would potentially arise out of such a positively formulated property clause. Subsequently, the final property clause in section 25 of the 1996 Constitution is negatively worded. This paper argues that a negatively framed property clause has had far-reaching and unintended consequences for land restitution as beneficiaries have no positive obligation to utilise land productively. Section 25 should be phrased positively so that it becomes easier to enact legislation and implement policies that encourage active, positive and productive utilisation of land. The German property clause is a good reference point to this effect.
References
Adams M and Howell J, ‘Redistributive Land Reform in Southern Africa’ (2001) Natural Resource Perspectives.
Alexander GS, ‘Property as a Fundamental Constitutional Right-The German Example’ (2002) Cornell Law Faculty Working Papers.
Alexander G, The Global Debate over Constitutional Property (University of Chicago Press 2006).
Aliber M, Maluleke T, Manenzhe T, Paradza G and Cousins B, Land Reform and Livelihoods – Trajectories of Change in Northern Limpopo Province (HSRC Press South Africa 2013).
Badenhorst PJ, Pienaar M J and Mostert H, Silberberg and Schoeman’s The Law of Property (Lexis Nexis 2006).
Bennett TW, ‘African Land - A History of Dispossession’ in Reinhard Zimmermann and Daniel Visser (eds) Southern Cross: Civil Law and Common Law in South Africa (Juta 1997). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198260875.003.0003
Bernstein A, Land Reform in South Africa: A 21st Century Perspective (Centre for Development and Enterprise 2005).
Berth E, ‘Costing Land Restitution 1994–2013’ (Parliament of the Republic of South Africa 2013).
Chaskalson M, ‘Property’ in Stu Woolman, Theunis Roux, Jonathan Klaaren, Anthony Stein, and Michael Bishop (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa (Juta 2006).
Commission on Restitution of Land Rights, Annual Report, 2007–2008.
Commission on Restitution of Land Rights, Annual Report 2015–2016.
Cousins B, ‘Introduction: Does Land and Agrarian Reform Have a Future and, If So, Who Will Benefit?’ in Ben Cousins (ed) At the Crossroads: Land and Agrarian Reform in South Africa into the 21st Century (PLAAS 2000).
Cousins B, Land Reform in Post-apartheid South Africa: A Disappointing Harvest.’ (University of Western Cape PLAAS 2009).
Cronje F, ‘How Much of SA’s Land is in Black Hands’ <http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71619/page71639 ?oid=282525&sn=Detail&pid=71639> accessed 13 May 2022.
Crush J, Power of Development (Psychology Press 1995).
Department of Land Affairs, Annual Report (2001) 1 April 2001–31 March.
Department of Land Affairs, ‘Medium-term Strategic and Operational Plan, 2002–2006.’
Department of Land Affairs, ‘Umhlaba Rural Service 2008, A Review of LRAD Project Performance (2001–2006).’
De Villiers B and Van Den Berg, ‘Land Reform: Trailblazers Seven Successful Case Studies’ (Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung 2006) 1–85.
Donald P, Kommers, Russel A and Miller M, The Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Federal Republic of Germany (3rd ed. Revised and Expanded Duke University Press 2012). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9780822395386
Ellse B, Costing Land Restitution 1994-2013 (Research Unit, Parliament of the Republic of South Africa 2013).
Everingham M and Jannecke C, ‘Land Restitution and Democratic Citizenship in South Africa’ (2006) Journal of Southern African Studies 545–562. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03057070600830508
Fay D and James D, (eds), The Rights and Wrongs of Land Restitution (Routledge-Cavendish 2009). DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203895498
Farmers’ Weekly, ‘The Ongoing Battle for Sustainable Land Reform in SA’ <http://www.farmersweekly.co.za/opinion/by-invitation/the-ongoing-battle-forsustainable-land-reform-in-sa/> accessed 7 July 2022.
Gibson J, Overcoming Historical Injustices – Land Reconciliation in South Africa (Cambridge University Press 2009). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511581632
Greenberg S, ‘The Landless People’s Movement and the Failure of Post-Apartheid Land Reform’ (2004) CCSRR 1, 33.
Greenberg S, ‘Redistribution and Access in a Market-Driven Economy - in Piecemeal Reforms and Calls for Action – Land Reform in South Africa’ (2003) Interfund Development Update.
Hall R, ‘A Comparative Analysis of Land Reform’ in Margaret C Lee and Karen Colvard (eds) Unfinished Business – The Land Crisis in Southern Africa (Africa Institute of South Africa 2003).
Hall R, ‘Land Restitution in South Africa: Rights, Development, and the Restrained State’ (2004) Canadian Journal of African Studies 654–671. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00083968.2004.10751302
Hall R ‘Transforming Rural South Africa? Taking Stock of Land Reform’ in Lungisile Ntsebeza and Ruth Hall (eds) The Land Question in South Africa – The Challenge of Transformation and Redistribution (HSRC Press 2007).
Hall R, and Ntsebeza L (eds), The Land Question in South Africa: The Challenge of Transformation and Redistribution (HSRC Press Cape Town 2007).
Hanstad T, ‘Land Reform in the 21st Century: New Challenges and Responses’ (2006) SJSJ 763–800, 768.
Hebinck P and Leynseele VY, ‘Through the Prism: Local Reworking of Land Restitution Settlements in South Africa’ in Derick Fay and Deborah James (eds) The Rights and Wrongs of Land Restitution (Routledge-Cavendish 2009).
Jacoby HG, Li G and Rozelle S, ‘Hazards of Expropriation: Tenure Security and Investment in Rural China’ (2002) American Economic Review 1420–1447. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/000282802762024575
James D, Gaining Ground: Rights and Property in South African Land Reform (Routledge-Cavendish 2006).
Letsoalo EM, Land Reform in South Africa – A Black Perspective (Skotaville 1987).
Levin R and Weiner D, ‘The Politics of Land Reform in South Africa after Apartheid: Perspectives, Problems, Prospects’ In The Agrarian Question in South Africa (Routledge 2014).
Kepe T, ‘The Problem of Defining ‘Community’: Challenges for the Land Reform Programme in Rural South Africa’ (2009) Development Southern Africa 415–433. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03768359908440089
Kleinbooi K, ‘Umhlaba Wethu’ - A PLAAS Bulletin Tracking Land Reform in South Africa.’7.
Kleyn D, ‘The Constitutional Protection of Property: A Comparison between the German and the South African Approach’ (1996) SAPL 402–445.
Lahiff E, Land Reform in South Africa: A Status Report. Programme for Land and Agrarian Studies (2008) Research Report No 38, 1.
Lubens R, ‘The Social Obligation of Property Ownership: A Comparison of German and US Law’ (2007) Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law 1–389.
McAuslan P, ‘Making Law Work: Restructuring Land Relations in Africa’ (1998) Development and Change 525–552. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-7660.00088
Mngxitama A, ‘The National Land Committee, 1994 – 2004: A Critical Insider’s Perspective.’ In Problematizing Resistance (2005) Centre for Civil Society Research Reports.’
Mostert H, ‘Engaged Citizenship and the Enabling State as Factors Determining the Interference of Property: A Comparison of German and South African Law’ (2010) South African Law Journal 238–273.
Mostert H, ‘Land Restitution, Social Justice and Development in South Africa’ (2002) South African Law Journal 400–428.
Murray C and O‘Regan C, ‘No Place To Rest’ (1989) SAJHR 361–394.
Nkwinti G, ‘How Land Ownership Will be Limited’ (2015) <http://www.info.gov.za/speeches/2010/10030311251002.htm> accessed 16 April 2022.
Ntsebeza L, ‘Land Tenure in South Africa: A Focus on the Moravian Church Land in the Western Cape’ in Competing Jurisdictions (Khanya College 2000).
Pienaar J M, Land Reform (Juta Cape 2014).
Plaatjie S T, Native Life in South Africa (PS King 1916).
Prosterman RL and Hanstad T, ‘Land Reform in the 21st Century: New Challenges and Responses’ (2006) Seattle Journal of Social Justice 763–800.
Prosterman Rl and Riedinger JM, Land Reform and Democratic Development (Johns Hopkins UP 1987) 36.
Roux T, ‘Pro Poor Court, Anti-Poor Outcomes: Explaining the Performance of the South African Land Claims Court’ (2004) SAJHR 522. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19962126.2004.11865162
Schlemmer L and Moller V, Migrant Labour in South Africa (Center for Applied Social Sciences University of Natal Durban 1981).
TCOE, Land is Life – The History of Land Dispossession in South Africa (Khanya College 2004).
The Economist, ‘Land Reform in South Africa – Hurry up’ <http://www.economist.com/node/15022632> accessed 15 April 2022.
Tilley S and Lahiff E, Batladi Community Restitution Claim‖ Research Report 31 PLAAS.
United Nations Development Programme, Human Development Report 2003: Millenium Development Goals – A Compact Among Nations to End Human Poverty 82.
Van der Walt AJ, ‘Property Rights, Land Rights and Environmental Rights’ in David Van Wyk, John Dugard, Bertus de Villiers and Dennis Davis (eds), Rights and Constitutionalism (Oxford University Press 1995).
Van der Walt AJ, ‘Towards the Development of Post-apartheid Land Law: An Exploratory Survey’ (1990) De Jure 1–45.
Van der Walt AJ, Constitutional Property Clauses (Juta 1997).
Walker C, ‘Redistributive Land Reform: For What and for Whom?’ in Lungisile Ntsebeza and Ruth Hall (eds) The Land Question in South Africa – The Challenge of Transformation and Redistribution (HSRC Press Cape Town 2007).
Walker C, Landmarked – Land Claims and Land Restitution in South Africa (Jacana Media (Pty) Ltd 2008).
Zille H, ‘Redressing Apartheid’s Original Sin’ (2013) Cape Times (25 January 2013) 9.
Cases
Agri SA v Minister for Minerals and Energy [2013] 4 SA 1 (CC).
Hamburg Flood Control [1968] 24 BVerfGE 367.
Elandskloof Vereniging Re: Plase Elandskloof Nr [1996] 476 ZALCC 4.
Ex Parte Chairperson of the Constitutional Assembly: In re Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa [1996] 4 SA 744 (CC).
Land Access Movement of South Africa and Others v Chairperson of the National Council of Provinces and Others [2016] 5 SA 635 (CC).
Policy Documents
National Development Plan 2030.
Legislation
Abolition of Racially Based Land Measures Act 108 of 1991.
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, 1990.
Constitution of Belgium, 1831.
Constitution of Japan, 1946.
Constitution of the Republic of Namibia, 1990.
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 200 of 1993.
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996.
Constitution of the United States of America, 1787.
Communal Property Associations Act 28, 1996.
Draft Tenure Security Policy and Draft Land Tenure Security Bill, 2010.
Extension of Security of Tenure Act 62, 1997.
Green Paper on Land Reform, 2011.
Land Reform (Labour Tenants) Act 3, 1996.
Natives Land Act 27, 1913.
Regulation of Agricultural Land Holdings Bill no 40697.
Restitution of Land Rights Act 22, 1994.
White Paper on South African Land Policy, 1997.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
© Published by the Department of Public, Constitutional and International Law, University of South Africa and Unisa Press.
