A Comparative Analysis of Implementing the Right to Water and Sanitation in South Africa and Türkiye in the Scope of Sen’s Capability Approach
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25159/2522-3062/16455Keywords:
right to water, capability approach, freedoms, urbanisation, inequalityAbstract
South Africa and Türkiye are two emerging markets that have witnessed significant migration from rural to urban areas over the past 50 years. A similar challenge in both countries is the growing demand for water, which increasingly exceeds supply, primarily due to climate change and expanding urban populations. While South Africa is regarded as a pioneer in the judicial interpretation of socio-economic rights, there is work to be done as far as advancing the implementation of the right to water. Meanwhile, Türkiye has a draft water law presently undergoing deliberations that draws lessons from South Africa and Brazil. However, further efforts are needed to establish a clear legislative framework that protects the right to water. This article aims to provide a comparative analysis of the law and policy in South Africa and Türkiye, while exploring their connection to the capability approach developed by Amartya Sen. The article will first look at South Africa’s specific position, then explore Türkiye’s framework. Finally, it will present a cross-country comparison of their approaches and offer recommendations for advancing the right to water in both nations. The main findings of the article suggest that, given the challenges of climate change and increasing urban populations, South Africa must learn from Türkiye in advancing the realisation of the right to water. This approach also contributes to expanding people’s freedoms in line with the principles of the capability approach.
References
3SMedia, ‘DWS Condemns Vandalism of Water and Sanitation Infrastructure’ Infrastructure New (4 April 2021) <https://infrastructurenews.co.za/2021/04/20/dws-condemns-vandalism-of-water-and-sanitation-infrastructure/> accessed 26 January 2024.
Acar M, et al., Impact Assessment Final Report, Local Administration Reform Project (LAR III) (May 2020).
Ağıralioğlu N and Mehr AD, ‘Principals of Planning and Realization of Greater Melen Water Supply Project, Turkey’(International Conference on Civil and Environmental Geology and Mining Engineering, Trazbon, Turkey, 20–22 April 2019, ICOCEM).
Akinyemi BE, Mushunje A and Fashogbon AE, ‘Factors Explaining Household Payment for Potable Water in South Africa’ (2018) 4 Cogent Social Science 1 <https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2018.1464379> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2018.1464379
Alıcı OV, ‘The Tendency Towards Centralization Experienced in the Management of Metropolitan Municipalities in Turkey’ (2021) 8 Journal of Economics and Administrative Sciences Faculty 1622 <https://doi.org/10.30798/makuiibf.911949> DOI: https://doi.org/10.30798/makuiibf.911949
Argüden Y, ‘From A Citizen’s Perspective: Governance Scorecard of Municipalities for Istanbul Districts’ (Argüden Governance Academy, No:12-E-2018).
Auditor-General South Africa, Auditor-General Releases Municipal Audit Results Under the Theme “Not Much to Go Around, Yet Not the Right Hands at The Till” 23 (July 2020).
Banda M, ‘Killer Cholera Hits Amid Decade-Long Bickering over Hammanskraal Water Crisis and Tender Scandals, Daily Maverick (23 May 2023) accessed 26 January 2024.
Berg SV, ‘Best Practices in Regulating State-Owned and Municipal Water Utilities’ (United Nations, Project Document, May 2013).
Bosson CB, ‘From Industry to Culture: Regeneration of Golden Horn as a “Culture Valley”’ (2019) 9 Turkish Online Journal of Design Art and Communication 491 <https://doi.org/10.7456/10904100/003> DOI: https://doi.org/10.7456/10904100/003
Burak S, Zeki S, Ülker D and Byırham I, ‘The Legal Framework of Water Quality Management in Turkey’ (2022) 6 Turkish Journal of Water Science and Management 121 <https://doi.org/10.31807/tjwsm.946225> DOI: https://doi.org/10.31807/tjwsm.946225
Carni T, ‘Enormous Amounts of Water are Wasted Daily – Now Municipalities are Being Told to ‘Stop the Leaks’ Daily Maverick (17 March 2022) accessed 22 January 2024.
Commission Staff Working Document, Türkiye 2016 Report, Accompanying the Document, Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee of the Regions, 2016 Communication on EU Enlargement Policy, {COM(2016) 715 final}.
Demiralp S and Balta E, ‘Defeating Populists: The Case of 2019 Istanbul Elections’ (2021) 26 South European Society and Politics 1 < https://doi.org/10.1080/13608746.2021.1923639> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13608746.2021.1923639
Department of Water Affairs, South Africa, Report on the Status of Sanitation Services in South Africa, 29 (March 2012).
Department of Water Affairs—Republic of South Africa, ‘Water for an Equitable and Sustainable Future’ 9 (National Water Resource Strategy June 2013).
Dugard J, ‘Can Human Rights Transcend the Commercialization of Water in South Africa? Soweto’s Legal Fight for an Equitable Water Policy’ (2010) 42 Review of Political Economics <https://doi.org/10.1177/0486613410368495> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0486613410368495
Edelman DJ, ‘Managing the Urban Environment of Istanbul, Turkey’ (2021) 9 Current Urban Studies 107 <https://doi.org/10.4236/cus.2021.91007> DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/cus.2021.91007
Enqvist JP and Zierogel G, ‘Water Governance and Justice in Cape Town: An Overview’ (2019) 6 Wires Water <https://doi.org/10.1002/wat2.1354> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/wat2.1354
Erkan HS, Çakmakcı M and Engin GO, ‘Revolutionizing Pollution Reduction in the Marmara Sea Through Innovative Technologies’ in İşinibilir M, Kideys AE and Malej A (eds) Ecological Changes in the Sea of Marmara ( Istanbul University Press 2024).
Esen B and Gumuscu S, ‘Killing Competitive Authoritarianism Softly: The 2019 Local Elections in Turkey’ (2019) 24 South European Society and Politics 317 <https://doi.org/10.1080/13608746.2019.1691318> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13608746.2019.1691318
European Investment Bank, Municipal Water Infrastructure Turkey, accessed 21 November 2023.
Fisher-Jeffes L, Carden K and Armitage N, ‘A Water Sensitive Urban Design Framework For South Africa’ (2017) 71 SSB/TRP/MDM <https://doi.org/10.18820/2415-0495/trp71i1.1> DOI: https://doi.org/10.18820/2415-0495/trp71i1.1
Fuo ON, ‘Local Government Indigent Policies in the Pursuit of Social Justice in South Africa Through the Lenses of Fraser’ (2014) 25 Stellenbosch Law Review 187.
Gimelli FM , Roger BC and JJ Bos, ‘The Quest for Water, Rights and Freedoms: Urban Informal Settlements in India’ (2018) 42 The International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 1080 <https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2427.12708> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2427.12708
Govender N and Reddy PS, ‘Urban Regeneration in South Africa: The Apartheid Legacy and Legislative Framework Re-Examined – The Case of Ethekweni Muncipality’ (2019) 11 African Journal of Public Affairs 83.
İlbank Annual Report 2021.
Indicator 6.1.1 Share of Population Using Safely Managed Drinking Water Services <https://sdg.tuik.gov.tr/en/6-1-1/>
International Budget Partnership South Africa, ‘How Transparent are Municipal Websites about the Goods and Services that Municipalities Procure?’ (Dullah Omar Institute 4 October 2016) <https://dullahomarinstitute.org.za/siteworkspace/sarchi-reports-04-12-2020/how-transparent-are-municipal-websites-about-the-goods-and-services-that-mun.pdf> accessed 15 January 2024.
International Crisis Group, Türkiye’s Syrian Refugees: Defusing Metropolitan Tension (Europe Report No. 248, 29 January 2018).
ISKI Istanbul Water and Sewerage Administration, 2021 Report.
Karadirek IE, ‘Urban Water Losses Management in Turkey: Legislation and Challenges’ (2016) 17 Anadolu University Journal of Science and Technology 572 <https://doi.org/10.18038/btda.67184> DOI: https://doi.org/10.18038/btda.67184
Kıbaroglu A and Baskan A, ‘Turkey’s Water and Policy Framework’ in Kibaroglu A, Scheumann W and Krammer A (eds) Turkey’s Water Policy: National Frameworks and International Cooperation (Springer 2011).
Kıbarogluö A, Sümer V and Scheumann W, ‘Fundamental Shifts in Turkey’s Water Policy’ (2012) 119 Mediterranee 27 <https://doi.org/10.4000/mediterranee.6453> DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/mediterranee.6453
Lavanchy GT, Kerwin MW, Kerwin GJ and McCarroll M, ‘The Optics of “Day Zero” and the Role of the State in Water Security for a Township in Cape Town’ (2019) 46 Water International 841 <https://doi.org/10.1080/02508060.2021.1946763> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02508060.2021.1946763
Lehohla P, ‘The State of Basic Service Delivery in South Africa: In-Depth Analysis of the Community Survey’ 20–26 (Statistics South Africa Report No. 03–01–22 2016).
Makiva M, Bob T and Davids G, ‘Efficacy of Public Participation Prior to Installation of Portable Toilets in South Africa: A Case of Makhaza Area in Cape Town, Western Cape Province’ (2021) 12 African Journal for Public Affairs 171.
Marois T and McDonald DA, Public Banks, Public Water: Exploring the Links in Europe (2022) Water International, 673 <https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003344292> DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003344292
Masindi V and Dunker L, The State of Water and Sanitation in South Africa (CSIR Built Environment Pretoria 2016).
Mbovane T, ‘In Drought-stricken Mandela Bay, Leaking Taps are Wasting Precious Water’ GroundUp (11 August 2022) accessed 25 January 2024.
McKernan B, ‘Turkey Drought: Istanbul Could Run out of Water in 45 Days’ The Guardian (13 January 2021) accessed 30 January 2024.
Mehta L, ‘Water and Development’ (2014) 15 World Development 59 <https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2013.12.018> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2013.12.018
Minister of Human Settlements Lindiwe Sisulu, (Media Statements) Minister Lindiwe Sisulu on Interventions to Curb the Spread of Coronavirus COVID-19 (25 March 2020).
Mirzabaev A et al., ‘Desertification’ in Shukla PR (ed), Climate Change and Land: An IPCC Special Report on Climate Change, Desertification, Land Degradation, Sustainable Land Management, Food Security and Greenhouse Gas Fluxes in Terrestrial Ecosystems 249–341 (IPCC 2019).
Morudu HD, ‘Service Delivery Protest in South African Municipalities: An Exploration Using Principal Component Regression and 2013 Data’ (2017) 3 Cogent Social Science 1 <https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2017.1329106> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2017.1329106
Mudombi S, ‘Access to Water and Sanitation in South Africa: A Renewal Call for More Action’ Daily Maverick (20 April 2020) accessed 3 January 2024.
Muller JIA, ‘Making Great Places Through the Right to the City: A South African Perspective’ in Patel Y, Minyuku N, Van Der Bank C, Mohan K and Orga A (eds) Proceedings of the Conference: Planning Africa 2014 – Making Great Places (International Convention Centre, Durban, South Africa, 19–22 October 2014) 279–306, 291.
Narayan D, Voice of the Poor: Can Anyone Hear Us? (Oxford University Press for the World Bank 2000) < https://doi.org/10.1596/0-1952-1601-6>
Nussbaum MC, Women and Human Development (Cambridge University Press 2000) < https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511841286>
Öztürk I and Altay DA, ‘Water and Wastewater Management in Istanbul’ 1–27 (Presented at the UNESCO HQ International Conference on Water, Megacities and Global Change, Paris, December 2015).
Pieterse M, ‘Development, the Right to the City and the Legal and Constitutional Responsibilities of Local Government in South Africa’ (2014) 131 The South African Law Journal 149
Quinot G and Liebenberg S, ‘Narrowing the Band: Reasonableness Review in Administrative Justice and Socio-Economic Rights Jurisprudence in South Africa’ (2011) 22 Stellenbosch Law Review 639.
Republic of South Africa, National Report for the Third United Nations Conference on Housing and Sustainable Urban Development: Habitat III (2016).
Republic of Türkiye National Report on NUA.
Republic of Turkey, National Report on the Implementation of the New Urban Agenda (March 2021).
Reyes GE and Govers M, ‘Social Inclusion and Social Leverage Foundations: A Theoretical Review’ (2018) 9 Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences <https://doi.org/10.2478/mjss-2018-0158> DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/mjss-2018-0158
Rodina L, ‘Human Right to Water in Khayelitsha, South Africa – Lesson from a Lived Experienced Perspective’ (2016) 72 Geoforum 58 <https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2016.04.003> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2016.04.003
Ruiters C, ‘Funding Models for Financing Water Infrastructure in South Africa: Framework and Critical Analysis of Alternatives’ (2013) 39 Water SA 313 <https://doi.org/10.4314/wsa.v39i2.16> DOI: https://doi.org/10.4314/wsa.v39i2.16
Saygi D, ‘Turkey at High Risk of Water Scarcity’ SUWANA Europe (7 February 2022) <https://suwanu-europe.eu/water-scarcity-turkey/> accessed 27 January 2024.
Sen A, Commodities and Capabilities (Oxford University Press 1999).
Sen A ‘Inequality Re-Examined’ (Harvard University Press-Cambridge, Massachusetts 1992).
Sen A, ‘Capability and Wellbeing’ in Nussbaum MC and Sen A (eds) in Quality of Life (Oxford University Press Inc 1993) < https://doi.org/10.1093/0198287976.003.0003>
Shailaja F, ‘Process and Outcomes: Participation and Empowerment’ in Clark DA, Biggeri M and Frediani AA (eds), A Multidimensional Poverty Framework (Palgrave Macmillan 2019).
Shepherd L, ‘If You’re Struggling, You May Be Eligible for Relief on your Municipal Bills in Cape Town’ The Daily Vox (16 September 2020) accessed 25 January 2024.
Simpson NP, Simpson KJ, Shearing CD and Ciroli LR, ‘Municipal Finance and Resilience Lessons for Urban Infrastructure Management: A Case Study from the Cape Town Drought’ (2019) 11 International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development 257 <https://doi.org/10.1080/19463138.2019.1642203> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19463138.2019.1642203
Smith L, ‘Municipal Compliance with Water Services Policy: A Challenge for Water Security’ 7, 11–13 (Development Planning Division: Working Paper Series No.10 2009).
Spatari M, ‘Water Quality in South Africa: Reports Show What Needs to be Fixed, and at What Cost’ The Conversation (14 June 2023) <https://theconversation.com/water-quality-in-south-africa-reports-show-what-needs-to-be-fixed-and-at-what-cost-207538> accessed 26 January 2024.
Staff Writer, ‘The Shocking State of South Africa’s Municipalities Uncovered’ Businesstech (1 July 2020) <https://businesstech.co.za/news/government/412459/the-shocking-state-of-south-africas-municipalities-uncovered/> accessed 23 January 2024.
Staff Writer, ‘Turkey Formulating New Law on Water Management: Erdoğan’ Daily Hurriyet (5 July 2021) accessed 27 January 2024.
Statista, Turkey: Urbanization from 2011 to 2021
Steyn NR, ‘The Realisation of the Constitutional Water Right in South African Cities Through Intelligent Water Management Technologies’ (PhD Dissertation Northwest University ETDs 2021).
Still D et al., ‘Basic Sanitation Services in South Africa: Learning from the Past, Planning for the Future, 108 (Report to the Water Research Commission by Partners in Development, WRC Report No. TT 414/09, September 2009).
Taking L, Chang CC, Pan S and Armitage NP, ‘Towards a Water Secure Future: Reflections on Cape Town’s “Day Zero” Crisis’ (2019) 16 Urban Water Journal 530 <https://doi.org/10.1080/1573062X.2019.1669190> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1573062X.2019.1669190
Taşkın B, ‘The 2019 Provincial Elections in Turkey: AKP’s Struggle to Retain Power Vis-A-Vis a Revitalized CHP’ (2021) 31 Regional and Federal Studies 461 <https://doi.org/10.1080/13597566.2020.1858811> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13597566.2020.1858811
Twidle H, ‘Shadow of a Drought: Notes from Cape Town’s Water Crisis’ (2022) 24 Interventions Journal of Postcolonial Studies 378 <https://doi.org/10.1080/1369801X.2021.2015708> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1369801X.2021.2015708
Turok I and Scheba A, ‘“Right to the City” and the New Urban Agenda: Learning from the Right to Housing’ (2018) Territory, Politics, Governance 494 <https://doi.org/10.1080/21622671.2018.1499549> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/21622671.2018.1499549
UN Habitat- World Cities Report 2022, Envisaging the Future of Cities 53 https://unhabitat.org/sites/default/files/2022/06/wcr_2022.pdf> accessed 14 November 2024.
WHO, Unicef, Water, Sanitation, Hygiene, and Waste Management for the COVID-19 Virus, Interim Guidance, 23 April 2020.
WHO, Unicef, Water, Sanitation, Hygiene, and Waste Management for the COVID-19 Virus, Interim Guidance, 29 July 2020: World Health Organisation, Guidelines for Drinking – Water Quality 45–76
World Bank Group, Turkey-Istanbul Water Supply and Sewerage Project <https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/157241474907076507/turkey-istanbul-water-supply-and-sewerage-project> accessed 21 November 2024.
World Bank Group, Urban Development accessed 14 November 2024.
Yenekapı Waste Water Treatment Plant assessed 05 December 2024.
Zavisca JR and Gerber TP, ‘The Socioeconomic, Demographic, and Political Effects of Housing in Comparative Perspective’ (2016) 42 Annual Review of Sociology 347 <https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-soc-081715-074333> DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-soc-081715-074333
Zindoga CGW, Lagardien A, Cousins D and Muanda C, ‘Reducing Vandalism and Increasing the Sustainability of Water and Sanitation Services’ (WISA Biennial Conference 2010).
Cases
Beja and Others v Premier of the Western Cape and Others 2011 (10) BCLR 1077 (WCC).
Chweu Local Municipality and Others v Sabie Chamber of Commerce and Tourism and Others [2021] 1 All SA 668 (SCA).
City Council of Pretoria v Walker 1998 (2) SA 363 (CC).
Dubestka and Others v Ukraine no. 30499/03, §§ 109–123.
Dzemyuk v Ukraine no. 42488/02, §§ 77–84, The Court also recalled Chapman v The United Kingdom no. 27238/95.
Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd v Resilient Properties (Pty) Ltd and Others; Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd v Sabie Chamber of Commerce and Tourism and Others [2020] 3 All SA 546 (SCA).
Hudorovič and Others v Slovenia App no. 24816/14 and 25140/14, Eur. Ct. H.R. (2020).
Kenya: Waweru v Republic (2007) AHRLR 149 (KeHC 2006).
Mazibuko and Others v City of Johannesburg and Others 2010 (4) SA 55 (CC).
Residents of Bon Vista Mansions v Southern Metropolitan Local Council 2006 (6) BCLR 625 (W).
South African Human Rights Commission v Agro Data CC and Another (39/2023) [2024] ZASCA 121.
Statutory Instruments
South Africa
City of Cape Town, Five-year Integrated Development Plan, July 2017–June 2022.
Municipal Infrastructure Grant 2020, GG 43495 (3 July 2020).
Municipal Systems Act 32 of 2000.
National Framework for Municipal Indigent Policies.
National Water Act 36 of 1998.
South African Constitution of 1996.
The Reconstruction and Development Programme.
Water Services Act 108 of 1997.
White Paper on National Water Policy.
Türkiye
Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and the Council of 23 October 2000, establishing a framework for community action in the field of water policy (EU Water Framework Directive).
Directive 2008/56/EC/ of the European Parliament and the Council of 17 June 2008, establishing a framework for community action in the field of marine environmental policy (EU Marine Strategy Framework Directive) L164/19.
Draft Water Law of 2014.
Istanbul SKI 2017 Report.
ISKI Istanbul Water and Sewerage Administration, 2021 Report.
ISKI Istanbul Water and Sewerage Administration, 2023 Report.
Law No. 2560 on the Establishment of the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality of 1984.
Law No.5216 on Metropolitan Municipalities of 2004.
Law No. 5393 on Municipalities of 2005.
Law No. 5302 on Special Provincial Administrations of 2005.
Turkish Constitution of 1982.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
© Published by the Department of Public, Constitutional and International Law, University of South Africa and Unisa Press.
