Spurring Copyright Rights Holders’ Innovation in the Digital Age Through a Statutory Remuneration Copyright Levy for Private Home Copying
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25159/2663-6549/16092Keywords:
authors, copyright levy, Copyright Amendment Bill, copyright holders, copyrights, private copying exceptionAbstract
The United Nations estimates that in the next few years the creative industry will constitute around 10% of global gross domestic product. The sector has shown a sharp spike of growth at 12% per annum, particularly in the developing world. In South Africa, copyright holders—particularly youths—involved in creative digital expressions are now victims of rampant digital copying of their works without compensation. South African legislators have been warned that without a private copying levy system, the introduction of private copying exceptions such as fair use under the current Copyright Amendment Bill of 2017 will have adverse economic effects on creators. The current copyright bill does not have a provision for a copyright levy despite carrying a private copying exception. The futility of copyright law enforcement in private homes lies in part with the constitutional right to privacy protection enshrined in the Bill of Rights and the administrative impracticalities around prosecuting millions of copyright infringers. This article’s finding is that private copying is inevitable and harms copyright holders’ remuneration. As such, the rejoinder to normalised deviant copying behaviour is a private copying levy.
References
Archary, Natasha. n.d. 2023. “Don’t Share Andre de Ruyter’s Book! Publishers Warn of Legal Action.” Kaya959. Accessed 16 June 2023. https://www.kaya959.co.za/uncategorized/dont-share-andre-de-ruyters-book-publishers-warn-of-legal-action/
Banja, J. 2010. “The Normalization of Deviance in Healthcare Delivery.” Business Horizons 53 (2): 139–148. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bushor.2009.10.006
Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works. 1886. https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ip/berne/
Blázquez, Francisco Javier Cabrera. 2011. “Private Copying Levies at the Crossroads.” In Who Pays for Private Copying?, edited by Susanne Nikoltchev. IRIS Plus 2011-4. European Audiovisual Observatory.
Branislav, Hazucha. 2017. “Private Copying and Harm to Authors: Compensation versus Remuneration.” Law Quarterly Review 133 (2): 269–295.
CISAC. 2020a. “Private Copying Global Study 2020.” CISAC. https://www.cisac.org/services/reports-and-research/private-copying-global-study
CISAC. 2020b. “New Private Copying Global Study Shows Potential for Better Remuneration of Rightsholders.” CISAC, 23 November 2020. Accessed 15 June 2023. https://www.cisac.org/Newsroom/news-releases/new-private-copying-global-study-shows-potential-better-remuneration
Committee on Legal Affairs. 2014. Report on Private Copying Levies. European Parliament, 17 February 2014. Accessed 16 June 2023. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/A-7-2014-0114_EN.html.
Copyright Amendment Bill, 2017. https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201811/copyright-amendment-bill-b13b-2017.pdf
Department of Arts, Culture, Science and Technology. 1998. “The Cultural Industries Growth Strategy (CIGS): The South African Music Industry,” https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/musicreport0.pdf
Department of Trade and Industry. 2011. Copyright Review Commission Report 2011. https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/crc-report.pdf
Department of Trade and Industries. 2022. Cultural and Creative Industries (CCI) Masterplan. Accessed 20 February 2024. http://www.nationalarchives.gov.za/sites/default/files/u4521/Annexure%20A%20-%20Creative%20Industries%20MasterPlan.pdf
Depoorter, Ben, and Sven Vanneste. 2005. “Norms and Enforcement: The Case Against Copyright Litigation.” Oregon Law Review 84 (4): 1127–1180.
De Waal, Shaun. 2023. “De Ruyter's Truth to Power Sold an Eye-Popping 16 444 Copies in One Week.” News24, 27 May 2023. Accessed 16 June 2023. https://www.news24.com/life/books/de-ruyters-truth-to-power-sold-an-eye-popping-16-444-copies-in-one-week-20203527
Duncan, Magnus Ebbo. 2020. The Economic Contribution of Copyright Industries in Ghana. Swiss-Ghanaian Intellectual Property Project Phase II (SGIP II).
Eloff, Herman. 2023. “Delete that PDF! Legal Action Awaits Those Illegally Sharing De Ruyter Ebook.” News24, 17 May 2023. Accessed 14 June 2023. https://www.news24.com/life/books/delete-that-pdf-legal-action-awaits-those-illegally-sharing-de-ruyter-ebook-20230517
Fischman-Afori, Orit. 2012. “The Evolution of Copyright Law and Inductive Speculations as to Its Future.” Journal of Intellectual Property Law 19 (2): 233–259.
Fisher, William. 2005. Promises to Keep. Technology, Law, and the Future of Entertainment. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Forere, Malebakeng A. 2021. Reforming the Right to Remuneration in the South African Copyright Amendment Bill. PIJIP/TLS Research Paper Series no. 67.
Gowers, A. 2006. Gowers Review of Intellectual Property. London: HM Treasury.
Guerrini, Federico. 2014. “Italy’s Artists Line Up to Support the Piracy Tax: How Much Should You Pay for the Right to Copy?” ZDNet, 25 March 2014. Accessed 21 February 2023. https://www.zdnet.com/article/italys-artists-line-up-to-support-the-piracy-tax-how-much-should-you-pay-for-the-right-to-copy/
Hugenholtz, B., L. Guibault, and S. van Geffen. 2003. The Future of Levies in a Digital Environment. Amsterdam: Institute for Information Law.
Hungwe, Brian 2024 “The Implications of the Internet and Technology on South Africa’s copyright holders’ remuneration: Lessons from the European Union and Ghana.” PhD diss., University of the Witwatersrand.
Karjala, Dennis S. 2013. ‘“Copying” and “Piracy” in the Digital Age.” Washburn Law Journal 52: 245–266.
Karjiker, Sadulla. 2014. “Justifications For Copyright: The Economic Justification.” South African Intellectual Property Law Journal 14: 13–41.
Kemp, Simon. 2023. “Digital 2023: South Africa.” Digital2023. 13 February 2023. Accessed 15 June 2023. https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2023-south-africa#:~:text=Mobile%20connections%20in%20South%20Africa%20in%202023&text=GSMA%20Intelligence's%20numbers%20indicate%20that,percent)%20between%202022%20and%202023
Kerr, Ian, Alana Maurushat, and Christian Tacit. 2003. “Technical Protection Measures: Tilting at Copyright’s Windmill.” Ottawa Law Review 34 (1): 7–82.
Kretschmer, Martin. 2011. “Private Copying and Fair Compensation: An Empirical Study of Copyright Levies in Europe.” Centre for Intellectual Property Policy & Management. Accessed 20 February 2024. https://www.wipo.int/edocs/mdocs/mdocs/en/wipo_ip_econ_ge_1_12/wipo_ip_econ_ge_1_12_refslides.pdf
Lauren. 2024. “Mobile App Download Statistics & Usage Statistics 2024.” Buildfire. Accessed 20 February 2024. https://buildfire.com/app-statistics/
Liebowitz, Stan J. 2004. “Alternative Copyright Systems: The Problems With A Compulsory License.” IP Central Review 1 (2): 2–19.
Litman, Jessica. 2005. “Sharing and Stealing.” Hastings Communications and Entertainment Law Journal 27: 1–50.
Liu, Joseph P. 2001. “Owning Digital Copies: Copyright Law and the Incidents of Copy Ownership.” William & Mary Law Review 42 (4): 1245.
Lukeman, Chris. 2009. “The Effect of Piracy in the Developing World.” International IP Policy, 22 November 2009. Accessed 23 June 2023. https://siulaw.typepad.com/international_ip_policy/2009/11/the-effect-of-piracy-in-the-developing-world.html
Matsukis, Janene. 2015. “Piracy is Everybody's Issue.” IT Web, 24 July 2015. https://www.itweb.co.za/content/p6GxRKqYXOrMb3Wj
Meller, Paul. 2008. “EU Revisits Copyright Levy Conundrum.” InfoWorld, 14 February 2008. Accessed 21 February 2023. https://www.infoworld.com/article/2642531/eu-revisits-copyright-levy-conundrum.html
Mills, Mary L. 1989. “New Technology and the Limitations of Copyright Law: An Argument for Finding Alternatives to Copyright Legislation in an Era of Rapid Technological Change.” Chicago-Kent Law Review 65 (1): 307–339.
Ncube, Caroline. 2018. “Private Copying Levies ‘A Must.’” MusicinAfrica, 24 April 2018. Accessed 16 June 2023. https://www.musicinafrica.net/magazine/private-copying-levies-must
Netanel, Neil W. 2003. “Impose a Non-Commercial Use Levy to Allow Free Peer-to-Peer File Sharing.” Harvard Journal of Law & Technology 17 (1): 1–84. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.468180
Nicholson, Denise Rosemary. 2019. “South Africa’s Copyright Amendment Bill: Its Genesis And Passage Through Parliament.” LIASA-in-touch 20 (2). Accessed 15 June 2023. https://infojustice.org/archives/41167
Oberholzer‐Gee, Felix, and Koleman Strumpf. 2007. “The Effect of File Sharing on Record Sales: An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Political Economy 115 (1): 1–42. https://doi.org/10.1086/511995
Oduor, Fredrick O. 2011. “The Internet and Copyright Protection: Are We Producing a Global Generation of Copyright Criminals?” Jeffrey S. Moorad Sports Law Journal 18 (2): 501–525. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1640253
Olubiyi, Ifeoluwa A. 2014. “Imposition of a Copyright Levy in Nigeria: Legal Justifications and Comparative Analysis.” Journal of Sustainable Development Law and Policy 4 (1).
Oksanen, Ville, and Mikko Valimaki. 2005. “Copyright Levies as an Alternative Compensation Method for Recording Artists and Technological Development.” Review of Economic Research on Copyright Issues 2 (2): 25–39.
Peitz, Martin, and Patrick Waelbroeck. 2004. “The Effect of Internet Piracy on Music Sales: Cross Section Evidence.” Review of Economic Research on Copyright Issues 1 (2): 71–79. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.511763
Pistorius, Tana, and Odirachukwu S. Mwim. 2019 “The Impact of Digital Copyright Law and Policy on Access to Knowledge and Learning.” Reading & Writing 10 (1): 1–7. https://doi.org/10.4102/rw.v10i1.196
Poort, Joost. 2013. “Copyright Levies.” In Handbook of the Digital Creative Economy, edited by Ruth Towse and Christian Handke, 235–246. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781781004876.00032
Pouris, Anastassios, and Roula Inglesi-Lotz. 2017. “The Contribution of Copyright-Based Industries to the South African Economy.” South African Journal of Science 113 (11–12): 1–7. https://doi.org/10.17159/sajs.2017/20160286
Recording Industry Association of America. 2005. “Music Industry Targets 765 Internet Thieves in New Round of Lawsuits.” RIIA, 28 July 2005. Accessed 15 July 2023. http://www.riaa.com/news/newsletter/072805.asp
Shaw, Jonathan G. 2024. “Music Piracy: Where Are We Today?” MusikAfrica, 25 August 2022. Accessed 20 February 2024. https://www.musicinafrica.net/magazine/music-piracy-where-are-we-today
Sedlar, Nejc, Amy Irwin, Martin Douglas, and Ruby Roberts. 2023. “A Qualitative Systematic Review on the Application of the Normalization of Deviance Phenomenon Within High-Risk Industries.” Journal of Safety Research 84: 290–305. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsr.2022.11.005
Trading Economics. “South Africa Imports of Electrical, Electronic Equipment.” Trading Economics, June 2023. Accessed 16 June 2023. https://tradingeconomics.com/south-africa/imports/electrical-electronic-equipment
Trosow, Samuel E. 2003. “The Illusive Search for Justificatory Theories: Copyright, Commodification and Capital.” Canadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence 16 (2): 217–242. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0841820900003702
Varian, Hal. 2005 “Copying and Copyright.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 19 (2): 121–138. https://doi.org/10.1257/0895330054048768
Vaughan, Diane. 1996. The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture and Deviance at NASA. Chicago: Chicago University Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226346960.001.0001
Visser, Conrad. 2006. “Technological Protection Measures: South Africa Goes Overboard. Overbroad.” South African Journal of Information and Communication, (7): 54–63.
Wicaksana, Fransiskus Asisi Arya Seta. 2022. “Digital Piracy in the Third World Countries.” Centre for Digital Society, 24 December 2022. https://cfds.fisipol.ugm.ac.id/2022/12/24/digital-piracy-in-the-third-world-countries/
Wabugo, Michael. 2021. “Introducing a Private Copy Levy Can Help Uganda’s Artistes.” The Observer, 8 December 2021. Accessed 16 June 2023. https://observer.ug/viewpoint/72112-introducing-a-private-copy-levy-can-help-uganda-s-artistes
Wood, Jessica A. 2010. “The Darknet: A Digital Copyright Revolution.” Richmond Journal of Law and Technology 16 (4): 1–60.
Zimmerman, Diane L. 2005 “Living Without Copyright in a Digital World.” Albany Law Review 70: 1375–1397.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright will be vested in Unisa Press. However, as long as you do not use the article in ways which would directly conflict with the publisher’s business interests, you retain the right to use your own article (provided you acknowledge the published version of the article) as follows:
- to make further copies of all or part of the published article for your use in classroom teaching;
- to make copies of the final accepted version of the article for internal distribution within your institution, or to place it on your own or your institution’s website or repository, or on a site that does not charge for access to the article, but you must arrange not to make the final accepted version of the article available to the public until 18 months after the date of acceptance;
- to re-use all or part of this material in a compilation of your own works or in a textbook of which you are the author, or as the basis for a conference presentation.
Accepted 2024-06-11
Published 2024-07-24