Existential Threats to the International Criminal Court: Making Sense of the Convergence of Disparate Geo-political Interests and Ideological Positions

Moses Retselisitsoe Phooko

doi:10.25159/2520-9515/11271

Authors

Moses Retselisitsoe Phooko North-West University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25159/2520-9515/11271

Keywords:

African Union, Delegitimisation of the ICC, International Criminal Court, Existential threats to the ICC, International justice, United States

Abstract

The establishment of the International Criminal Court (ICC) in 1998 was welcomed by many as a progressive step towards ending the impunity of those who commit international crimes. However, there appears to be serious legitimacy and existential threats to the ICC. Those at the forefront of the attack on the ICC, such as the United States of America (United States) and the African Union, have fundamentally different geo-political interests and pursue largely different ideological positions. The reasons advanced by these disparate enemies of the ICC are different but are largely informed by the different fears they have for the Court. This article aims to expose the various interests behind the efforts to delegitimise and destroy the ICC. The article also seeks to demonstrate the different strategies used by the ICC’s nemeses in their attacks on the Court. To achieve this, the article provides an overview of the relationship of various United States administrations with the ICC. I trace the United States’ initial support for the ICC and, thereafter, try to set out why it suddenly morphed into one of the Court’s foremost nemeses. I also outline the various strategies that the United States has employed in its attack on the ICC. I then discuss the AU’s troubled relationship with the ICC, starting with the AU’s overwhelming endorsement of the ICC project, to the current situation where there is a general view within the body that the Court is anti-African. I attempt to unpack the reasons for this troubled relationship between the AU and ICC. I also outline the strategies the AU (and some of its Member States) employs in its attack on the ICC. I conclude by positing that it is crucial for those who may want to save the ICC from collapse to understand the different fears of its nemeses and the different strategies they have been employing to destroy it. It is only through such an understanding that formidable counter strategies may be employed to mitigate the legitimacy and existential threats to the ICC.

References

Adejo, A. 2001. “From AOU to AU: New Wine in Old bottles?” Australian Journal of International Affairs 4:119−141.

African Union. 2009. “Decision on the Meeting of African State Parties to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal,” 3 July 2009, AU Doc. Assembly/AU/Dec. 245(XIII) Rev. 1, para. 10; and ‘Decision on the International Criminal Court”, 28–29 January 2018, AU Doc. Assembly/AU/Dec. 672(XXX), paras. 2(iii)–3(i) and 5. Accessed 13 January 2023 https://reliefweb.int/report/sudan/decision-meeting-african-states-parties-rome-statute-international-criminal-court-icc.

African Union. 2014. “Decision on the Draft Legal Instruments,” Assembly/AU/Dec.529(XXIII). Accessed 13 January 2023 https://archives.au.int/bitstream/handle/123456789/172/Assembly%20AU%20Dec%20529%20%28XXIII%29%20_E.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.

Amann, D and Sellers M. 2002 “The United States of America and the International Criminal Court.” The American Journal of Comparative Law 50:381−404. https://doi.org/10.1093/ajcl/50.suppl1.381 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ajcl/50.suppl1.381

AU Assembly, “Decision on the Implementation of the Assembly Decisions on the International Criminal Court (ICC),” 30 June-1 July 2011, AU Doc. Assembly/AU/Dec. 366(XVII), paras. 5–6.

Bachmann, S and Sowateyi-Adjei, N. 2020. “The African Union-ICC Controversy Before the ICJ: A Way Forward to Strengthen International Criminal Justice.” Washington International Law Journal 29(2):247−301.

Benzing, M. 2004. “U.S. Bilateral Non-surrender Agreements and Article 98 of the Statute of the International Criminal Court: An Exercise in the Law of Treaties.” Max Plank UNYB 8:181−236. https://doi.org/10.1163/138946304775159756 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/138946304775159756

Bolton, J. 2018. “Protecting American Constitutionalism and Sovereignty from International Threats”. Accessed 19 February 2022. https://www.justsecurity.org/60674/national-security-adviser-john-bolton-remarks-international-criminal-court/

Boschiero, N. 2015. “The ICC Judicial Finding on Non-cooperation Against the DRC and no Immunity for Al Bashir Based on UNSC Resolution 1593.” Journal of International Criminal Justice 13(3):625−653. https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqv034 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqv034

Cassese, A and Paola G. 2013. International Criminal Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Chigara, B and Nkwanko, C. 1998. “To be or Not to be?’ The African Union and its Member States Parties’ Participation as High Contracting States Parties to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.” Nordic Journal of Human Rights 33(3):243−268. https://doi.org/10.1080/18918131.2015.1105559 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/18918131.2015.1105559

Cowley, E “U.S. Policy Regarding the International Criminal Court (ICC).” Accessed 19 February 2022. https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/RL31495.html#fn1.

Cryer, R. Friman H, Robinson D, Wilmshurst, E. 2014. An Introduction to International Criminal Law and Procedure. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107588707 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107588707

Danilenko, G. 2000. “The Statute of the International Criminal Court and Third States.” Michigan Journal of International Law 21(3):445−494.

Elsea, J. 2006. “U.S. Policy Regarding the International Criminal Court.” Accessed 13 January 2023. https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/RL31495.html

Falk, R. 2012. “Opening the Other Eye: Charles Taylor and Selective Accountability.” Accessed 3 May 2022. https://www.globalpolicy.org/international-justice/the-international-criminal-court/us-opposition-to-the-icc/51549-opening-the-other-eye-charles-taylor-and-selective-accountability.html?itemid=id#164.

Griner, V. 2008. “United States’ Special Agreements: Consistency with the Object and Purpose of the Rome Statute of the ICC.” Revista De Derecho 29:211−236.

Hans-Peter, K. 2007. “The International Criminal Court: Current Challenges and Perspectives.” Washington University Global Studies Law Review 6: 575−582.

ICC. 2022. “About the Court, International Criminal Court.” Accessed 27 April 2022.

https://www.icc-cpi.int/about/the-court

ICC. 2021. “Situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan ICC-02/17.” https://www.icc-cpi.int/afghanistan.

ICC. 2020. “Situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan No. ICC-02/17 OA4”, 5 March 2020. Accessed 13 January 2023. https://www.icc-cpi.int/victims/situation-islamic-republic-afghanistan.

Ikenberry, G. 2005. “Power and Liberal Order: America’s Post-war World Order in Transition.” 5 International Relations of the Asia-Pacific 5 (2): 133−152. https://doi.org/10.1093/irap/lci112 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/irap/lci112

Jesssberger, W and Werle, G. 2014. Principles of International Criminal Law. Oxford. Oxford University Press

Johansen, R. 2006. “The Impact of US Policy toward the International Criminal Court on the Prevention of Genocide, War Crimes, and Crimes against Humanity.” Human Rights Quarterly 28(2):301−331. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.2006.0020 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.2006.0020

Kayitana, E. 2018. “States Criminal Jurisdiction Under International Law: Fostering a Common and Better Understanding.” Nnamdi Azikiwe University Journal of International Law and Jurisprudence 9:14.

Kempster, N. 2001 “U.S. May back Creation of Special Atrocity Tribunals.” Accessed 5 February 2022. www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2001-aug-02-mn-29777-story.html.

Kennedy, M. 2017. “Under New leader, Gambia Cancels Withdrawal from International Criminal Court.” Accessed 8 May 2022. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/02/14/515219467/under-new-leader-gambia-cancels-withdrawal-from-international-criminal-court.

Koh, H. and Buchwald T. 2015. “The Crime of Aggression: The United States Perspective.” American Journal of International Law 109:257−295. https://doi.org/10.5305/amerjintelaw.109.2.0257 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5305/amerjintelaw.109.2.0257

Nel, M. and Sibiya, V. 2017 “Withdrawal from the International Criminal Court: Does Africa Have an Alternative?” African Journal on Conflict Resolution 17(1):79−103.

Nkhata, M. 2011. “Along Came Omar Al Bashir to Malawi: International Criminal Law and the Immunity of Heads of State.” Malawi Law Journal 5(2):149−160.

Omorogbe, E. 2019. “The Crisis of International Criminal Law in Africa: A Regional Regime in Response?” Netherlands International Law Review 66:287−311. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40802-019-00143-5 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40802-019-00143-5

Phooko, M. 2011. “How Effective the International Criminal Court Has Been: Evaluating the Work and Progress of the International Criminal Court.” Notre Dame Journal of International Law 1: 182−209.

Perez, A. 2016. “ICC finds Uganda and Djibouti Failed to Comply with Request for Arrest and Surrender of Al Bashir.” Accessed 15 April 2021. www.asil.org/blogs/icc-finds-uganda-and-djibouti-failed-comply-request-arrest-and-surrender-al-bashir-july-11.

Prosper, P. 2002. “The Position of the US in Prosecuting Atrocities Around the World.” Accessed 2 March 2022. www.pbs.org/wnet/wideangle/interactives-extras/interviews/media-by-milosevic-interview-ambassador-pierre-richard-prosper/985/.

Reeves, T. 2000. “A Global Court? U.S. Objections to the International Criminal Court and Obstacles to Ratification.” Human Rights Brief 8(1): 15−30.

Rossen, A. and Griner, V. 2007. “Article 98 Agreements: Legal or Not”. Thesis, University of Orebro.

Rhea, H. 2009. “The United States and International Criminal Tribunals: An Historical Analysis.” ILSA Journal of International and Comparative Law 16(1):19−38.

Sadat, L. and Drumbl, M. 2006. The United States and the International Criminal Court: A Complicated, Uneasy, Yet at Times Engaging Relationship Washington University in St. Louis 8. Accessed 13 January 2023. https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1504&context=wlufac.

Schabas, W.A., 2020. An Introduction to the International Criminal Court. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108616157 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108616157

Shendruk, A. 2019. “The UN’s Reliance on the US Could be its Downfall.” Accessed 2 May 2022. www.qz.com/1728368/the-uns-funding-reliance-on-the-us-could-be-its-downfall/.

Simons, M. and Specia M. 2019. “U.S. Revokes Visa of ICC Prosecutor Pursuing Afghan War Crimes.” Accessed 19 January 2021. www.nytimes.com/2019/04/05/world/europe/us-icc-prosecutor-afghanistan.html.

Sterio, M. 2019. “The Trump Administration and the International Criminal Court: A Misguided New Policy Case.” Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law 51: 201−210.

Ssenyonjo, M. 2018. “State Withdrawal Notifications from the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: South Africa, Burundi, and the Gambia.” Criminal Law Forum 29: 63−119. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10609-017-9321-z DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10609-017-9321-z

Ssenyonjo, M. 2013. “The Rise of the African Union Opposition to the International Criminal Court’s Investigations and Prosecutions of African Leaders.” International Criminal Law Review 13:385−428. https://doi.org/10.1163/15718123-01302002 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/15718123-01302002

Taft, H and Wald P. 2009. US Policy Toward the International Criminal Court: Furthering Positive Engagement. American Society of International Law

Tunamsifu, S. 2019. “Twelve Years of Judicial Cooperation Between the Demographic Republic of Congo and the International Criminal Court: Have Expectations Been Met?” African Human Rights Law Journal 19 (1): 105−125. https://doi.org/10.17159/1996-2096/2019/v19n1a6 DOI: https://doi.org/10.17159/1996-2096/2019/v19n1a6

Van der Vyver, J. 2011. “Prosecuting the President of Sudan: A Dispute Between the African Union and the International Criminal Court.” African Human Rights Law Journal 11:683−698.

Williamson, C. 2007. “The Role of the United States in International Criminal Justice.” Penn State International Law Review 25(4): 819−831.