Gerrymandering in Municipal Demarcation Processes in South Africa: Selected Cases of the Collins Chabane and JB Marks Local Municipalities

Mpfareleni Mavis  Netswera; Valiant Clapper

doi:10.25159/2663-6689/11332

Authors

Mpfareleni Mavis Netswera University of South Africa https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0408-6019
Valiant Clapper University of South Africa

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25159/2663-6689/11332

Keywords:

redistricting, gerrymandering, municipal boundary determination/re-determination, local government, South Africa, Municipal Demarcation Board

Abstract

This article focuses on political processes, specifically redistricting, which is the political process of redrawing electoral boundaries within which people contest local government elections. It has, however, become common practice for the political party in power to review electoral boundaries in its favour, a practice known as gerrymandering. In South Africa, municipal boundary review, which takes place every five years to either determine new boundaries or re-determine existing boundaries for the purposes of municipal elections, has always given rise to objections. The reasons for such objections range from the lack of public participation in the demarcation process to public perceptions of the value of belonging to one municipality as opposed to another, tribalism, and service delivery concerns. The main findings emanating from the scrutiny of literature on municipal boundary determination protests and the two municipal case studies in South Africa revealed elements of gerrymandering motivated by the political aspirations of those in power.

References

Africa News Agency. 2015. “Ventersdorp/Potch Merger is not Welcome: Residents.” http://www.enca.com/south-africa/ventersdorppotch-merger-not-welcome-%E2%80%93-residents.

Ansolabehere, S., and M. Palmer. 2015. “A Two Hundred-year Statistical History of the Gerrymander.” Presentation at the Congress and History Conference, Vanderbilt University, May 22–23.

Auditor General South Africa (AGSA). 2021. Consolidated General Report on the Local Government Audit Outcomes MFMA 2019–20.

Brunell, T. L. 2006. “Rethinking Redistricting: How Drawing Uncompetitive Districts Eliminates Gerrymanders, Enhances Representation and Improves Attitudes toward Congress.” Political Science and Politics 39 (1): 77–85. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1049096506060173. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S1049096506060173

Cameron, R. 2006. “Local Government Boundary Reorganisation.” In Democracy and Delivery: Urban Policy in South Africa, edited by U. Pillay, R. Tomlinson, and J. du Toit. Cape Town: HSRC.

Collins Chabane Local Municipality. 2017. LIM345 Local Municipality 2017/18–2022 adopted IDP.

Cooper, M. 2010. 5 “Ways to Tilt an Election.” http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/weekinreview/20100925-redistricting-graphic.pdf?mcubz=1.

Citizens Research Council of Michigan (CRCM). 2011. Congressional and Legislative Redistricting Reform. Report 370.

Department of Co-operative Governance. 2015. Annual Report for the 2014/15 Financial Year.

Department of Cooperative Governance. 2020. Annual Report for the 2019/20 Financial Year.

Dr Kenneth Kaunda District Municipality. 2017. Final Integrated Development Plan 2017/18–2021/22.

Iyer, L., and M. Reddy. 2013. “Redrawing the Lines: Did Political Incumbents Influence Electoral Redistricting in the World’s Largest Democracy?” Working Paper 14.

JB Marks Local Municipality. 2017a. Integrated Development Plan, 2017–2022.

JB Marks Local Municipality. 2017b. 2016/2017 Unaudited Draft Annual Report.

Khumalo, B., and M. Ncube. 2016. “Financial and Functional Viability and Sustainability of Municipalities: Beyond the Demarcation Instrument.” Paper presented to the MDB Conference on Demarcation and Spatial Transformation, 23–24 June.

Lawrence, C. N. 2016. “Geography of Representation: Gerrymandering, Representation and Turnout.” In Why don’t Americans Vote? Causes and Consequences, edited by B. A. King and K. Hale. 2016. California: ABC-CLIO.

Local Government Sector Education and Training Authority (LGSETA). 2020. “Research on Exploring Factors Affecting Governance in Local Government Institutions.”

Mackenzie, J. 2010. Gerrymandering and Legislator Efficiency. Newark: College of Agricultural Sciences, University of Delaware.

Mafikeng Mail. n.d. “Cope Decries Amalgamation of Ventersdorp, Tlokwe Municipalities.” https://www.northwestnewspapers.co.za/mafikengmail/community/blogs/letters/98-cope-decries-ama.

Magubane, K. 2015. “Midvaal and Emfuleni Municipal Merger Set Aside for Now.” http://www.bdlive.co.za/national/politics/2015/09/23/midvaal-and-emfuleni-municipal-merger-set-aside-for-now.

Maryland Redistricting Reform Commission (MRRC) 2015. Maryland Redistricting 2015 Report. Annapolis: State of Maryland.

Matemba, L. 2000. “Challenges Facing New Municipalities.” Southern African Catholic Bishops’ Conference Parliamentary Liaison Office Briefing Paper 36.

Mavungu, M. E. 2012. “Ideological Clashes behind Provincial Boundary Disputes in Post-Apartheid South Africa.” South African Geographical Journal 94 (1): 60–74. https://doi.org/10.1080/03736245.2012.675734. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03736245.2012.675734

McGluwa, J. 2015. “Opposition for Tlokwe and Ventersdorp Merger is Widespread.” https://www.dampl.co.za/2015/10/opposition-for-tlokwe-and-ventersdorp-merger-is-widespread.

Mdumela, T. G. 2016. “What Tribal Affinities Have to Do with Local Government Service Delivery.” Unpublished Master’s Dissertation, University of Limpopo.

Mokgosi, D. 2013. “Metsimaholo-Ngwathe Merger Off.” http://fstimes.co.za/?p=1307.

Mukwevho, N. 2016. “Tribal Tension between the Venda and Tsonga Groups Fuel Conflict in Vuwani.” http://www.sowetanlive.co.za/news/2016/05/09/ tribal-tension-between-the-venda-and-tsonga-groups-fuel-conflict-in-vuwani.

Municipal Demarcation Board (MDB). 2014. Municipal Demarcation Board Annual Report 2013/14: Celebrating 15 Years of Spatial Transformation.

Municipal Demarcation Board (MDB). 2015a. Redetermination of the Boundary of the Thulamalela Local Municipality by Excluding Malamulele Area and Determining this Area as a Separate Category B Municipality within the Vhembe District Municipality.

Municipal Demarcation Board (MDB). 2015b. “Municipal Demarcation Board Responds to High Court Ruling in DA vs MDB Court Interdict.” Press release, 6 November 2015.

Municipal IQ. 2009. “The Intricacies of Re-demarcation.” Briefing #161, 8 October 2009.

Mzakwe, S. 2016. “The Legality of the 2015 Demarcation Proposals by the Minister of Cooperative Governance to the Municipal Demarcation Board.” Master’s Degree, University of the Western Cape.

Napier, J. C. 2007. “Delimitation of Local Government Ward Boundaries in the Tshwane Municipal Area: The Challenge of Achieving Fair Political Representation.” Politeia 26 (2): 179–191.

Netswera, M. M. 2019. “The Effects of Municipal Demarcation on Service Delivery and Social Integration in Collins Chabane and JB Marks Local Municipalities.” PhD thesis, University of South Africa.

Nicolson, G. 2017. “Vuwani: After the Ashes, there’s Hope.” https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2017-05-05-vuwani-after-the-ashes-theres-hope/#.WrOq5mpuapo.

Ntombana, L., and T. Khowa. 2020. “Relationship between Municipal Performance (Service Delivery) and Communities’ Rejection/Acceptance of Demarcations.” International NGO Journal 15 (2): 7–15. https://doi.org/10.5897/INGOJ2020.0349. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5897/INGOJ2020.0349

Nxumalo, C. 2013. “Municipal Boundary Demarcation in South Africa: Processes and Effects on Governance in Traditional Rural Areas.” Unpublished Master’s Dissertation, University of Cape Town.

Parliamentary Monitoring Group (PMG). 2021. “State of Local Government.” https://pmg.org.za/blog/State%20of%20Local%20Government.

Politics and Policy. n.d. “Gerrymandering: Proving All Politics is Local.” http://politicsandpolicy.org/article/gerrymandering-proving-all-politics-local.

Preston, K. 2021. “Overcoming Gerrymandering: Analyzing Past Approaches and Looking to Automation to Overcome Bias and Cognitive Limitations in Florida.” Stetson Law Review 50: 659–686.

Ratto Trabucco, F. 2019. “Gerrymandering Hypothesis in the Italian Constituencies: The Case of Genoa’s District.” https://doi.org/10.35295/ osls.iisl/0000-0000-0000-1039.

Rasila, B. N., and M. E. Musitha. 2017. “Assessing Challenges to Ineffective Communication in Government Institutions: A Case Study of Vuwani Area, Limpopo, South Africa.” Africa’s Public Service Delivery and Performance Review 5 (1): 1–10. https://doi.org/10.4102/apsdpr.v5i1.177. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4102/apsdpr.v5i1.177

Republic of South Africa. 1996. Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996. Pretoria: Government Printer.

Republic of South Africa. 1998. Local Government: Municipal Demarcation Act (Act 27 of 1998). Pretoria: Government Printer.

Shale, V. 2005. “Demarcating Local Authorities’ Boundaries for Good Governance versus the People-to-people Relations: The Case of Lesotho.” EISA Occasional Paper number 28 (January), 1–12.

Tau, P. 2020. “Vuwani Divided over Boycott of Municipality as Lack of Services Becomes ‘Unbearable’.” https://www.news24.com/citypress/news/vuwani-divided-over-boycott-of-municipality-20200314.

The Citizen. 2015. “DA Opposes Merger of Tlokwe and Ventersdorp Municipalities.” http://citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/446267/da-opposes-merger-of-tlokwe-and-ventersdorp-municipalities/.

Tiva, W. 2017. “Shutdown of Services in Vuwani Called Off.” http://www.sabc.co.za/news/a/ad6f73804ff91a7f9c53dd2890c6dd6e/ShutdownundefinedofundefinedservicesundefinedinundefinedVuwaniundefinedcalledundefinedoff-20170602.