A Comparative Study of the Challenges of Being Independent: Case studies (Botswana Independent Electoral Commission and Electoral Commission of Zambia)

Leonard L. Sesa

doi:10.25159/0256-8845/3272

Authors

Leonard L. Sesa University of Botswana

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25159/0256-8845/3272

Keywords:

Botswana, elections, Zambia, electoral management body, democracy, commissioners

Abstract

Elections in a democracy are a way to bring about a peaceful transfer of power in an organised and peaceful manner within a legal framework. However, this process, in most countries, carries with it elements of uncertainty and tension. Southern African countries like Botswana and Zambia have more experience with comparative democratic electoral politics than others. This article seeks to identify the legal framework that govern and the weaknesses and opportunities that exist in the electoral commissions of Botswana and Zambia in order to eradicate the current challenges faced by election management bodies (EMBs); more importantly, it seeks to understand their image as impartial players in the conduct of general and other elections that are held in Botswana and Zambia in order for the SADC region to learn from these two EMBs. The purpose of this article is to critically compare and analyse the independence of the Zambia Electoral Commission and the Botswana Independent Electoral Commission, in order to establish the extent of the adequacy of the legal frameworks that govern their independence. The article argues that an EMB has to win the confidence of all stakeholders in the electoral process.

References

Commonwealth Observer Report 2006. Zambia Presidential National Assembly and Local Government Elections: 28 September 2006. Commonwealth Secretariat: Zambia:

FODEP Report 2002. Electoral reform strategy: past, present and future activities. The foundation for Democratic Process: Zambia, Lusaka.

Mambilima, J.I. C. 2013. Paper presented on experiences and lessons from Zambiaâ€™s 2011 elections: Electoral Commission of Zambia: Lusaka.

Molomo, M.G. 2006. Democracy and Botswanaâ€™s electoral system. Journal of African Elections, vol 5, no. 2: 33â€“34. DOI: https://doi.org/10.20940/JAE/2006/v5i2a2

Muchangani K. 2012. The independence of the Electoral Commission of Zambia and the appointment of the election date by the president. University of Zambia: Zambia.

Mwaba, C.E. 2011. The Electoral Commission of Zambia: the challenge of being autonomous and independent. University of Zambia- School of Law Zambia.

Okello, E.O. 2006. Guaranteeing the independence of election management bodies in Africa: a study of the electoral commission of Kenya and South Africa. University of Pretoria: Pretoria.

Phirinyane, M.B. 2013. The dynamics of electoral governance. Botswana Institute of development Policy Analysis (BIDPA): Light Books: BOTSWANA.

Republic of Botswana 1966. Constitution of Botswana. Government Printer: Gaborone.

Republic of Botswana 1968. Electoral Act. Government Printer: Gaborone.

Rukambe, J. 2010. Performance audit of the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) in respect of the Botswana 2009 general elections. IEC: Gaborone.

Sebudubudu, D. and Osei- Hwedie, B. Z. 2005. Democratic consolidation in SABC: Botswanaâ€™s 2004 elections. EISA Research Report No 11. Electoral Institute of Southern Africa (EISA): Johannesburg.

Sebudubudu, D. and Botlhomilwe, M. Z. 2010. The management of elections: The case of Botswana. Politeia vol 29 no. 1. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02589001.2011.581501

Sebudubudu, D. 2008. Enhancing democratic governance through credible elections in the SADC Region Symposium to mark the 10th Anniversary of the Electoral Commissions Forum of SADC Countries (ECF-SADC), Bwawani Hotel Conference Hall, Zanzibar United Republic of Tanzania, 26 July.

The International IDEA Handbook. 2006. International IDEA: Sweden.

The Government of Zambia. 1996. The Constitution of Zambia. Government Printer: Lusaka, Zambia.

Tsie, B. 2003. The role, functions and performance of Botswanaâ€™s Independent Electoral Commission. Journal of African Election, vol. 2, no. 1: 145â€“151. DOI: https://doi.org/10.20940/JAE/2003/v2i1a12

Tsie, B. 2008. The Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) of Botswana at ten achievements and challenges. Paper presented at a symposium on Transparency and fairness. Ten years of Building Credibility and trust in the Electoral Process, 11 December, Phakalane Golf Estate Resort, Gaborone.

White, J. 2005. â€˜Independent Communications Authority of South Africa. In Constitutional Law of South Africa, ed.Woolman, S; Roux, T., Klaaren, J., Stein, A, and Chaskalson M. Johannesburg: Juta.